AVSIM Commercial Scenery Review

Scenery Tech

South America Landclass

Product Information

Publisher: Scenery Tech

Description: Addon Scenery

Download Size:
11.3MB

Format:
Download
Simulation Type:
FSX
Reviewed by: Etienne Martin AVSIM Staff Reviewer – November 5, 2008

Introduction:

Scenery Tech’s South America Landclass replaces the default terrain classification data for the South American continent.

As with ST’s products for North America, Europe and Asia, the purpose of the landclass replacement for South America is to increase the accuracy and the level of detail in the coverage area.  The product claims to effectively reduce the omnipresent desert-like textures where detail was neglected in Flight Simulator’s default scenery database.

The flight simulator scenery engine uses the Olson Global Ecosystem Legend to map terrain types to the world map.  This data is compiled the USGS Earth Resources Observation and Science Center (EROS).  The maximum level of detail is provided in Flight Simulator for a terrain type is 1.2 square kilometers or less than ½ square mile.

There are 255 possible terrain classes, and some of these types are shown in the table below:

 

0

Ocean, Sea, Large Lake

40

Cool Grasses And Shrubs

131

Dirt

 

1

Large City Urban Grid Wet

41

Hot And Mild Grasses And Shrubs

132

Coral

 

2

Low Sparse Grassland

42

Cold Grassland

133

Lava

 

3

Coniferous Forest

43

Savanna (Woods)

134

Park

 

4

Deciduous Conifer Forest

44

Mire Bog Fen

135

Golf Course

 

5

Deciduous Broadleaf Forest

45

Marsh Wetland

136

Cement

 

20

Cool Rain Forest

46

Mediterranean Scrub

137

Tan Sand Beach

 

27

Conifer Forest

53

Barren Tundra

143

Glacier Ice

 

29

Seasonal Tropical Forest

54

Cool Southern Hemisphere Mixed Forests

144

Evergreen Tree Crop

 

33

Tropical Rainforest

60

Small Leaf Mixed Woods

146

Desert Rock

 

South America landclass coverage, default FSX – data is color coded by landclass Scenery Tech’s South America landclass coverage, using same color coding - note the increased level of detail.

The side by side visual comparison of the default landclass versus Scenery Tech’s shows some differences, notably around the edge of population areas, in mountainous terrain, and even in vast expanses of rainforest.   Unlike the Asia product I reviewed earlier this year, the South America product includes data for the entire continent, not just certain population centers.  Clearly, it seems Scenery Tech has much better source data for this continent than for some of the more remote parts of Asia.

Installation and Documentation:

Each product comes as an 11Mb download – rather small as scenery products go.  The e-commerce solution is provided by Flight 1.  Installation requires an internet connection and upon credit card payment, the main setup program is unlocked and automatically started.  This e-commerce method remains one of the easiest to use on the market, and also supports re-installs and updates.

Speaking of which, Scenery Tech provides free updates to existing customers. The South America product we discuss here is release 1.0.

The install is completely automatic and a simple affair.

E-commerce welcome screen Unlocked setup program Optional textures for slope textures and rocks

Scenery Tech provides some replacement textures for slopes and rocks, which can help the overall effect.   ST does not recommend installing those if you have a texture replacement add-on as it may cause artifacts or conflicts.   I didn’t notice any such impact on my other scenery add-ons, although none are specific to the area covered by this Scenery Tech product.  My texture add-on does have instructions on how to deal with landclass products, in particular, the order in which the landclass data appears in the scenery library.  Impact should be minimal, and the feature can be turned off in case a problem occurs.

Backups of the specific files are made on setup if you decide to install them, so it is always possible to copy the modified data back. 

Overall, the entire data set occupies approximately 10Mb on disk.

The documentation for the South America landclass comes in the form of a 5 page RTF format document.  The document looks identical to that for all other Scenery Tech Landclass products, the only difference being the reference the modified coverage area.   The document includes a map of the coverage area, basic installation instructions, and a useful list of files impacted by the texture replacement feature and how to undo it.  Since the product really has no options outside of being enabled in the scenery library (or not), the documentation is actually quite complete.

Visuals:

We’ll use the Terrain Mesh File (TMF) tool in the Flight Simulator SDK to compare landclass data “before” and “after”, some satellite view snapshots followed by in flight images using the same view point to illustrate the differences. 

Landclass data comparison

Venezuela, FSX – The pixels colors represent different terrain types (TMF) Venezuela, ST - significant differences inside the country, with gradiated variations
Brazil, FSX – The pixels colors represent different terrain types (TMF) Brazil, ST – again much more detail inland, and smoother transitions from rural to high population density areas
Ushuaia, Argentina, FSX – satellite view Ushuaia, Argentina, ST – notice the difference in terrain rendering in the top left and top right
Georgetown, Guyana, FSX – satellite view Georgetown, Guyana, ST – coverage is different and has more accurate tropical textures.
Cucuta, Columbia, FSX – satellite view Cucuta, Columbia, ST – subtle differences in population areas, not so subtle change in terrain classification top left.

Observations:

Scenery Tech South America radically alters the terrain in two ways.  Firstly, it adds what visually looks to be at least 4 times the data points to the default scenery.  Second, it provides smoother transitions between terrain types, making the resulting scenery much more realistic, even if we are far from photo-real.   The effect can be drastic in poor coverage areas, and more subtle in places where FSX already includes some good data.

La Paz, Bolivia, FSX La Paz, Bolivia, ST
Angofasta, Chile, FSX Angofasta, Chile, ST
Mount Pleasant, Falkland Islands, FSX Mount Pleasant, Falkland Islands, ST – drastic improvement here
Andes mountains near lake Titicaca, Peru, FSX, Andes mountains near lake Titicaca, Peru, ST
Looking N of Cuzco, Peru, FSX Looking N of Cuzco, Peru, ST – note the effects of the rock textures in the top left

Performance:

Test System

Intel QX9650 @ 4GHz
4 GB of RAM
NVIDIA 8800 Ultra
CH Products controllers
Windows Vista 64
FSX Acceleration/SP2

FS Global 2008 X Mesh

Flying Time:
5 days

I did not notice any impact on frame rates with this product.

Conclusion:

Scenery Tech brings some detailed landclass data to the South American continent, in a set that appears very complete, more so than Scenery Tech’s Asia product. Within the limits of the supported terrain types in FSX, the end result is well worth it.  The effect is immediately apparent - even drastic in some areas. The product shines noticeably in reducing the vast expanses of bland scenery in areas neglected by FSX while adding good variety where possible.

In the end, the product adds pleasing visuals which directly translates to a new level of immersion for flights in that part of the world.

 

What I Like About Scenery Tech Landclass - South America

  • In many cases, transforms the landscape over default scenery data
  • Increases level of detail everywhere in the South American continent
  • Smoothes transitions between terrain types
  • Very small disk footprint as far as scenery add-ons go
  • Increases visual appeal and interest

 

What I Don't Like About Scenery Tech Landclass - South America

  • There is really nothing not to like about this product

 

Printing

If you wish to print this review or read it offline at your leisure,  right click on the link below, and select "save as"

Scenery Tech Landclass - South America

(adobe acrobat required)

Comments?

Standard Disclaimer
The review above is a subjective assessment of the product by the author. There is no connection between the producer and the reviewer, and we feel this review is unbiased and truly reflects the performance of the product in the simming environment. This disclaimer is posted here in order to provide you with background information on the reviewer and any connections that may exist between him/her and the contributing party.

Tell A Friend About this Review!

© 2008 - AVSIM Online
All Rights Reserved