Question for Southwest Airlines Classic Downloaders

[Mac_Paint 35]

Captains,I noted that the Southwest Airlines Classic livery available on our download server has a rating of 2.5 stars while the other four available liveries have ratings of 5.0. As the artist responsible for this livery, I'm curious as to what it is about this particular paint that has earned it this rating. If you've rated this livery less than 5 can you please let me know what leads you to this rating. I'd love to have a chance to address any concerns you have about this one.Thanks.

[Guest Jeff Berman]

Pete,I for one find nothing wrong with the Southwest Classic livery. I put my rating of 5 in there to help you out :) Are you going to do any of the special liveries for Southwest?

[Mac_Paint 35]

Jeff,thanks for the rating. My real reason for the posting is not to raise the rating but to determine what if anything is incorrect that earns this livery a lower rating. As for additional SWA liveries, there are a slew of them waiting to get on the server. Most of the 700 based SWA liveries are done and a few 400/500 series liveries have been applied to the 600/700 and will also be made available.

[Gridley 257]

My guess is that people just like the 'other' southwest paint better for aesthetic reasons. I for one LOVE your classic. Dresses the new bird up just right!sg

[MrHoward 7]

I can see nothing wrong with the paint at all that would warrant a 2.5 rating.Perhaps it was a booboo? I know I didn't vote when I downloaded it - I will return and do so - perhaps that would help.

[Guest Jeff Berman]

Thanks Pete :-wave

[Guest Mark McG]

Pete,any chance of a winglets version of both ;)

[Mac_Paint 35]

They are both done and only waiting their turn for installer writing.

[Guest Mark McG]

Thanks Pete.

[Guest ba747heavy]

Pete,My 2 cents US: There is nothing wrong with her :)

[Guest sk400hvy]

I second the "booboo" option! :)I'm having a hard time understanding why any of your planes deserve anything less that full score. You've done a lot of repaints on the PMDG airpark and all have been top notch!CheersAndy

[Tabs 2,790]

I think people might be rating based on much they like the aesthetics of the livery, rather than the quality/completness of the repaint. Please don't do this folks - even if the livery is ugly as sin on the real airplane, you should rate it based on how accurately it's reproduced for the NG!!

[Azapata87 173]

hi,Your SWA classic livery is all I fly I refuse to fly any other livery or airline.Andrew

[Guest moshe_be]

Maybe some bored people with all the holidays just rated all planes 1 a few times?