HTC Vive vs Rift VR for P3D?

[theskyisthelimit 48]

Having pre-ordered an Oculus Rift Retail version.. i had already thought i was set on the Rift as it had slightly higher resolution.  But reviews overall (for gaming) seem to point to Vive.. slightly less resolution but 360 degrees of view vs 180 with Rift, though i dont think this is a deal changer for Rift, as in my cramped office this would be more ideal for Rift (still hoping my area isnt too small.. a 10x12 room with maybe 6 x 6 for the desk area).

 

At any rate.. i know there is this FlyInside software for making Rift work better with P3D.. but has anyone looked into Vive.. does it also work.. which works better and feels more real with P3D?

EDIT: looks like they added Vive support..

 

Curious on any real experience so far?

 

Thanks

[Melchor 18]

You mean Vive, dont you?

[theskyisthelimit 48]

You mean Vive, dont you?

Darn autocorrect  HTC Vive yeah.  Fixed

[Terrydew 6]

I have both and have used both with Flyinside. I recommend the Rift as better for sim with P3D. IMHO the screen is a good bit better as I can read all the dials and frequencies without leaning in. Since you are not moving around most of the pluses for the Vive go away.

 

Terry

[glider1 90]

I've heard rumours from youtube that the brightness of the Vive image is better than rift. Does the Rift reproduce natural colours, contrast and brightness convincingly or does it feel like you are looking the world through thick sunglasses?

[denali 74]

[06R 2]

Any update on this?  I have a rift due in the next few weeks but I am unsure about it now and I am considering cancel that order and going with vive... anyone had some air time with both?

[Sethos 4,298]

Rift if you want to support a cancerous company.

 

Vive if you don't.

[06R 2]

What is the general feedback on which is best in sim?  The reports I read say the rift has a larger area where the image is in focus and very clear - which is what you want in a sim.  Vive is much smaller which can result in viewing issues in big jets etc.  Anyone got any feedback on that?

[Cargostorm 151]

I also thought about VR for P3D, but you need nearly twice the performance as with a monitor. Hardware is just not ready to enjoy VR in high resolution and decent FPS

[be77solo 125]

I also thought about VR for P3D, but you need nearly twice the performance as with a monitor. Hardware is just not ready to enjoy VR in high resolution and decent FPS

I'm in line with this, tech just isn't there yet to make me want to replace a nice widescreen monitor.

 

Even taking out the PC performance aspect, I think generation 2 or 3 of these will be when things might start to change.

[06R 2]

I also thought about VR for P3D, but you need nearly twice the performance as with a monitor. Hardware is just not ready to enjoy VR in high resolution and decent FPS

 

I see plenty of people on here running 2 or even 3 screens?  VR runs 1080 x 1200 x 2 so not that crazy really.I suspect 1080 or 1080ti will cope with that. 

[Marek2704 6]

Maybe someone is an owner of Vive/Rift and GTX 1080 and can write about flight sim experience?

[irrics 1,517]

I had the rift and used it with flyinside for about a week before returning it.

 

The immersion and feel of flying is wonderful. The resolution on the screens is just too frustratingly low which makes any sort of flying beyond helicopters and sightseeing just too cumbersome for me.

 

Seeing things in the distance clearly requires using various assists and even a general instrument scan is very difficult due to the resolution and some gauges been really hard to read.

 

I would recommend getting it from a place where you can return it. Version two of these headsets with higher resolution will be when this really takes off for serious flight simulation usage. The immersion is game changing...just needs a bit more resolution for me.

[glider1 90]

Why not set up EZDOK views with the Rift if the resolution is a bit low?