TCAS RA Scenario?

[wrap23 27]

I would like to demonstrate the maneuver for responding to TCAS RA. Is there a way to set that up or do you have to deliberately "run down" a virtual aircraft target?

Thanks,

Don

[scandinavian13 5,192]

9 hours ago, wrap23 said:

do you have to deliberately "run down" a virtual aircraft target?

This....but:

9 hours ago, wrap23 said:

I would like to demonstrate the maneuver for responding to TCAS RA.

Please have a look at the EULA for your product.

[wrap23 27]

Kyle,

I appreciate the aircraft that PMDG has developed and respect the talent of the individuals that created them. I have purchased the rights to entertain myself with a couple of those aircraft.

The other evening the topic of discussion with my son made its way to aviation, aviation accidents, and then further to aircraft warning systems. I don't believe I violated the EULA that I agreed to when I attempted to show my son what a simulated TCAS RA might look like in the comfort of my own home.

"This software may not be used to demonstrate the airplane, airplane systems, operational norms, flows, procedures or other pilot knowledge application in a classroom or training environment without being supplemented by the appropriate commercial license."

After 36 years in aviation terms such as "scenario" and "demonstrate" are just part of my lexicon. 

Respectfully,

Don Spence

 

Edited December 13, 2018 by wrap23

[Olympic260 415]

2 hours ago, wrap23 said:

Kyle,

I appreciate the aircraft that PMDG has developed and respect the talent of the individuals that created them. I have purchased the rights to entertain myself with a couple of those aircraft.

The other evening the topic of discussion with my son made its way to aviation, aviation accidents, and then further to aircraft warning systems. I don't believe I violated the EULA that I agreed to when I attempted to show my son what a simulated TCAS RA might look like in the comfort of my own home.

"This software may not be used to demonstrate the airplane, airplane systems, operational norms, flows, procedures or other pilot knowledge application in a classroom or training environment without being supplemented by the appropriate commercial license."

After 36 years in aviation terms such as "scenario" and "demonstrate" are just part of my lexicon. 

Respectfully,

Don Spence

 

Don on your initial post you had not clarify what exactly meant by demonstrate hence Kyle EULA mention. Of course showing it your son is not breaking the EULA 🙂

[ph-cxz 28]

Since it has been clarified with what the demonstration meant. It is not possible in the sim it self as there is no target available. For this you would need to be on vatsim or ivao. Then it can only happen when you have another pilot willing to help you plus an air traffic controller who accepts the demonstration and guides you into an area where it can be tested so to speak.

note Do have a look at the guidelines for vatsim and ivao as what can be done. The controller is the boss in this.

Edited December 13, 2018 by ph-cxz
Added info

[Olympic260 415]

4 minutes ago, ph-cxz said:

Since it has been clarified with what the demonstration meant. It is not possible in the sim it self as there is no target available. For this you would need to be on vatsim or ivao. Then it can only happen when you have another pilot willing to help you plus an air traffic controller who accepts the demonstration and guides you into an area where it can be tested so to speak.

note Do have a look at the guidelines for vatsim and ivao as what can be done. The controller is the boss in this.

Not true. AI traffic can be seen in the TCAS. No need to be online in a network. When I fly offline I am using UT Live and have TCAS targets normally.

[ph-cxz 28]

8 minutes ago, Olympic260 said:

Not true. AI traffic can be seen in the TCAS. No need to be online in a network. When I fly offline I am using UT Live and have TCAS targets normally.

While I agree with you on that I probably should have clarified that mine was more of a complete package involving atc. 

[scandinavian13 5,192]

8 hours ago, wrap23 said:

Kyle,

I appreciate the aircraft that PMDG has developed and respect the talent of the individuals that created them. I have purchased the rights to entertain myself with a couple of those aircraft.

The other evening the topic of discussion with my son made its way to aviation, aviation accidents, and then further to aircraft warning systems. I don't believe I violated the EULA that I agreed to when I attempted to show my son what a simulated TCAS RA might look like in the comfort of my own home.

"This software may not be used to demonstrate the airplane, airplane systems, operational norms, flows, procedures or other pilot knowledge application in a classroom or training environment without being supplemented by the appropriate commercial license."

After 36 years in aviation terms such as "scenario" and "demonstrate" are just part of my lexicon. 

Respectfully,

Don Spence

 

I would ask that you return to my earlier post and note the lack - in entirety - of an accusation of a violation. I asked you to review the EULA because your reference to "scenario" and "demonstrate" were unclear. Nothing more. If I believed there were an actual issue, I would have stated as much. If anything, it was an extension of trust - in other words, I was unclear on your intent, but trusted you to have a look at the EULA and make that determination on your own.

After 36 years in aviation, the concept of clear communication should be par for the course. If your response to a controller were vague, you'd get push back of some sort. That doesn't mean they're kicking off an ATSAP and giving you a phone number.

Edited December 13, 2018 by scandinavian13