An interesting opinion from outside the echo chamber

[Alan_A 1,650]

4 minutes ago, Doug47 said:

What are you even talking about?  

I believe that was sarcasm.

I'll put my NDA at risk to this extent: the critique in the original post isn't accurate.

End of statement.

[Doug47 574]

2 minutes ago, Alan_A said:

I believe that was sarcasm.

I'll put my NDA at risk to this extent: the critique in the original post isn't accurate.

End of statement.

Thank goodness. I was about to reinstall Windows Vista and load up version 1 of FSX. You saved me Alan!!

[Alan_A 1,650]

1 minute ago, Doug47 said:

Thank goodness. I was about to reinstall Windows Vista and load up version 1 of FSX. You saved me Alan!!

Why FSX?  FS4 runs so much better!

[Jeff Nielsen 1,386]

This entire post is idiotic to say the least.  The sim is in Alpha.  Most things are NOT going to work by definition...lol.  In fact, MS just posted publicly a lot of things that are still broke...ROFL!

Edited April 27, 2020 by Jeff Nielsen

[hs118 707]

1 minute ago, Jeff Nielsen said:

This entire post is idiotic to say the least.  The sim is in Alpha.  Most things are NOT going to work by definition...lol.  In fact, MS just posted publicly a lot of things that are still broke...ROFL!

Amazing, you are here...posting in this idiotic thread 🙂 

MHO, several of the commenters have made very cogent and well thought arguments.

PS still the lack of Donors, even by those most judgmental.

 

[Jeff Nielsen 1,386]

4 minutes ago, yurei said:

Amazing, you are here...posting in this idiotic thread 🙂 

MHO, several of the commenters have made very cogent and well thought arguments.

PS still the lack of Donors, even by those most judgmental.

 

Because I'm not a donor?  I used to be on staff here years ago.  I've put in my time, if you want to use that argument.

Bottom line:  The sim is NOT supposed to be fully working at this point, so we're all arguing about nothing.  It doesn't matter if the the person that posted those original comments are correct or not.  The fact is we know that they are correct based on the developers own public statements.  So what?  

[mp15 138]

I dont care about this article, scenery is very important and It Is there. Dynamics could be always improved gradually as well as IFR.

Flight control mappings will eventually be perfect for PC and regarding Xbox i dont care.

[SierraHotel 979]

Well, at least it's added a new dynamic to the "P3D is better than X-Plane is better than P3D"! And by the way, there is only one opinion that matters....Mine.....and yours. Make you're own minds up and stop listening to some swivel head with an axe to grind.

[hs118 707]

19 minutes ago, Jeff Nielsen said:

so we're all arguing about nothing.  It doesn't matter if the the person that posted those original comments are correct or not.  The fact is we know that they are correct based on the developers own public statements.  So what?  

So how does this thread differ from all the other speculative threads? And why does your opinion of it matter more than anyone else's? Again, if the thread is idiotic, you are commenting here too.

[Doug47 574]

2 minutes ago, yurei said:

So how does this thread differ from all the other speculative threads? And why does your opinion of it matter more than anyone else's? Again, if the thread is idiotic, you are commenting here too.

Nobody said the thread is idiotic. The quote from the original post you made is idiotic. 

[hs118 707]

Just now, Doug47 said:

Nobody said the thread is idiotic. The quote from the original post you made is idiotic. 

That is a factually incorrect statement. Please read all the posts.

[Doug47 574]

Just now, yurei said:

That is a factually incorrect statement. Please read all the posts.

Its not when I'm making. :)

The quote from the original post you made is idiotic 👍

[Jeff Nielsen 1,386]

1 minute ago, yurei said:

So how does this thread differ from all the other speculative threads? And why does your opinion of it matter more than anyone else's? Again, if the thread is idiotic, you are commenting here too.

For one thing, I'm saying it's not speculative.  I'm not breaking my NDA by saying that either because the developers have stated that publicly.

You're correct, I got sucked in to yet another thread.  You're also, still not listening to what's being said.  It's not a matter of opinions, it's a matter of facts.  I didn't say my opinion matters more than any one else.

 

[Jeff Nielsen 1,386]

3 minutes ago, Doug47 said:

Nobody said the thread is idiotic. The quote from the original post you made is idiotic. 

I actually said the thread itself was idiotic....lol

[hs118 707]

3 minutes ago, Jeff Nielsen said:

You're correct, I got sucked in to yet another thread.  You're also, still not listening to what's being said.  It's not a matter of opinions, it's a matter of facts.  I didn't say my opinion matters more than any one else.

There are no public facts if there is an NDA. That said @Alan_A said it as well as anyone can.

In all fairness to you, you did get sucked into another thread. Honestly, it was at its best when it devolved into comedy. 

Edited April 27, 2020 by yurei