FSX XP vs Vista Screenshot Comparisons

[Buckster 0]

I've done the best I can to get same settings in both, same ATI Control catalyst options (for AA, AF etc), and as near as I can same sort of view - but its hard with 2 seperate OS, with 2 different installations of FSX - anyway this is the best I can doDefinately for some reason, there is NO FSAA or AF being applied in XP - with my ATI X1900XT anyway, textures don't look as sharp as in Vista either, and I'm fairly sure its not all to do with the FSAA and AF not being applied it seems more than that.XP FSX screenies seem "muddy" looking to me.First out of each pair = XP - 2nd Vista Differences are more obvious at original screen res shots of 1600x1200 -but hopefully you can still see quite a difference.Your comments are welcome.cheers, Mark.next pairnext pair

[Guest EGLD]

Great screenshotsIs Vista now running DirectX 10? From what I hear the latest builds (5840 and RTM) have DirectX 10, or has that been the case throughout the beta cycle?Geoff

[Buckster 0]

not sure to be honest - if I do dxdiag, it says Directx10 - but not sure if that means anything or not - I'm not sure if it really is.I'm using build 5744don't get me wrong, I'm no (well wasn't) Vista fan-boy -it ran games like a dog only a few months back when I was trying out Beta 2 and RC1 - but the combo of RC2 + ATIs RC2 driver -its superb. Now my operating system of choice out of my 2 boots.Mark.

[Buckster 0]

I can't really emphasise how much of a difference I've found the whole game in Vista vs XP.until 3 days ago, FSX was the most disappointing game I had bought for a long long while, and I was playing it very sporadically, playing my other games instead.Under Vista though - I haven't been able to peel myself away from FSX - it now looks good with decent enough performance.Mark.

[Guest EGLD]

I'm wondering if Vista is now in full DirectX 10 'mode', it might explain the differences in the screenshots here, and the fact FS9 does not work for me in Vista 5840, 3D is all screwed upFSX however, runs fantastic in 5840...ThanksGeoff

[Buckster 0]

not sure if it would make a difference, as the ATI driver will be DX9, and my card is DX9 only too.I too get some weirdies though - Lockon is superb under Vista -but above clouds, and clouds are purple !Gothic 3 - is a screen full of large textures ! like if you overclock too high.What card do you have ?Mark.

[Magic Man 2]

Not really know what the point of this thread is.You're comparing what FSX looks like in XP under DX9 to what it looks like in the pre-release version of Vista running on a DX9 card under DX9?

[Buckster 0]

Because(1) With my X1900XT I can only get FSAA and AF to work in FSX (Enabling it in game in XP does add a bit of FSAA - but it seems to be a sofware based FSAA IMO, and no AF applied)(2) I'm getting sharper textures (could be due to AF not being applied in XP)(3) With all the above, I'm getting better performance, smoother performance (much less stutters) - its just hard to do a comparison one to the other -but performance is definately better.Hence why the thread.Mark.

[Mike T 208]

Vista has had DX10 since at least Beta2.

[remilton 66]

Have you tried ATI Tray Tools to enable you FSAA and AF in XP? Works for me.http://downloads.guru3d.com/download.php?det=733

[Clutch Cargo 384]

Interesting. I really couldn't see a difference based on the screenshots (maybe due to size compression here in the forums), but If I am hearing you correctly, all things being equal, just using Vista improves quality of the picture and improves fps? Nothing else?

[Noel 4,484]

>Vista has had DX10 since at least Beta2.Then it's time to retry this experiment with a new nV 8800 DX10 card, unless there are no DX10 drivers for it.

[mrthorlacius 0]

Correct me if im wrong, but DX10 effects will not appear until a patch from the Aces team activates all the benefits of DX10, even if you have FSX running on Vista, right? By the way I

[JSkorna 137]

Correct! All you are seeing is DX9 software running in a DX10 environment!Jimhttp://www.hifisim.com/Active Sky V6 Development Team Active Sky V6 Proud SupporterHiFi Beta TeamRadar Contact Supporter: http://www.jdtllc.com/AirSource Member: http://www.air-source.us/FSEconomy Member:http://www.fseconomy.com/

[Noel 4,484]

Bring it on MS/Vista/DX10/Patch! FSX sales will go up (in my house anyway) when this happens!