Propeller Spinning Graphic

[Flaps30 3]

I recently went for a scenic flight in a Cessna 172 and sat in the front' right seat. As we slowly taxied along the runway to take off I could see the spinning propeller through the windshield somewhat similar to what it looks like in Flight Sim.  However, once the throttle was advanced  to takeoff  speed  and  then at cruise only a faint arc from the outer edge of the blades could be detected and the main prop was practically invisible.

In Flight Sim the spinning prop appears visible and unrealistic when the throttle is advanced to full. In the Flight Sim 152 and 172 the graphic changes very little from taxi through takeoff when it should be at full throttle and changes very little while at cruise when only a faint arc should be seen.  I have the A2A 172 for Prepar3d and they have it pretty close to the real thing.  I thought they would have adjusted this in the new FS2020 version but apparently not. I saw a post suggesting a switch to turn off the visible blades to just the hub as a quick fix.  Is this possible or can the speed of the blades be adjusted in the config file? The props in FS2020 twin aircraft spin somewhat unrealistically also but are no problem through the front windshield obviously since the props are to the sides... If an adjustment for higher rpm situations such as takeoff and cruise settings could be made would make a huge difference. We already have the taxi and landing prop speeds.

[roland 28]

there is a mod at flightsim.to

[WestAir 2,522]

I've read on these boards that this is intentional. What was previously said was that flight Sims have, historically, taken the cinematic liberty of modeling how moving props look on film, as opposed to through eyes.

That's just what I've seen explained here, anyway.

Edited March 21, 2022 by WestAir

[pmb 5,137]

I agree to the OP that the original animation is nasty. There are even several variants of realistic propeller animations at flightsim.to, the one I still use for several planes is more than a year old.

https://flightsim.to/file/3412/10-propeller-mods-for-the-fs2020-standard-edition

https://flightsim.to/file/3623/6-propeller-mods-for-the-fs2020-premium-deluxe-edition

Kind regards, Michael

[Flaps30 3]

Thanks for the replies guys.  It's good to see that I'm not the only one who sees this. It simply comes down to the prop animations are unrealistic in higher RPM situations such as takeoff and cruise settings. We can use the slower animations for taxi, ,landing, and idle situations.

WestAir is right. We aren't trying to simulate the playback of a video recording of a flight where you will see awkward views of the prop due to the limitations of video playback rather than the actual flight itself.     Tom 

Edited March 22, 2022 by Flaps30

[-Belga- 139]

IMO, this is by far the best prop animation mod. It covers more than 50 propeller airplanes (default and payware):

VR Friendly Prop Mod MULTI PASS!

Edited March 22, 2022 by -Belga-

[Flaps30 3]

Thanks Belga for your help.

Does this mod work with the new 2020 version?     

[-Belga- 139]

14 hours ago, Flaps30 said:

Does this mod work with the new 2020 version?     

What do you mean with "the new 2020 version"?

[cianpars 1,164]

1 hour ago, -Belga- said:

What do you mean with "the new 2020 version"?

I think he means the latest sim update.

[Twenty6 692]

21 hours ago, Flaps30 said:

Does this mod work with the new 2020 version?     

Haven't tried all the different planes, but what I have tried worked really well in the current version of MSFS2020 (v1.23.12)

Works OK without VR also.

[BufordTX 50]

On 3/22/2022 at 10:40 AM, Flaps30 said:

Thanks Belga for your help.

Does this mod work with the new 2020 version?     

Works in sim update 8.

[Flaps30 3]

Sorry guys for not wording what I was referring to clearly.  Cianpars is right..

I was referring to the new Flight Sim 2020 rather than FSX, Prepar3d, etc.

Edited March 24, 2022 by Flaps30

[-Belga- 139]

2 hours ago, Flaps30 said:

I was referring to the new Flight Sim 2020 rather than FSX, Prepar3d, etc.

The link leads to flightsim.to, a page solely dedicated to MSFS. So yes, the mod works in MSFS.

[Flaps30 3]

Hi Belga,

Your prop mod looks great. I'm not that technically inclined. How is it installed?

[109Sqn 1,554]

13 hours ago, Flaps30 said:

Hi Belga,

Your prop mod looks great. I'm not that technically inclined. How is it installed?

Like 99% of addons for MSFS, just unzip and drop into your Community Folder (or whichever folder you have created for addons if you use Addons Linker)

(Note that it was created by @BufordTX who posted above😉 ).

Edited March 25, 2022 by 109Sqn
typo