6 hours ago, Matthew Kane said:

Not sure where you guys got "Final Report" from when I was only ever talking about the Preliminary Report. A preliminary report provides a concise summary of factual information gathered during the initial phase of an accident or incident investigation. It is typically released within a few weeks of the event. From there you have a better idea based on facts not speculation

LRBS I never once said "Final Report" that was on you. If you wish to continue to speculate before a Preliminary Report that is fine. I prefer to wait for the Preliminary Report, don't put words in people mouths I never once said Final Report

When a Preliminary Report is released that is when Tubers like Juan Browne or Captain Steeeve release detailed analysis based on the Preliminary Report which to be honest is the responsible thing to do.

Something is missing here. I didn't mention anywhere that you said "final report". Can you point me to that sentence where you claim that I put words in people's mouths? Again, what seems to be the problem with you about me speculating like other people? Did you also go after the other people? 

Your Juan Browne Blancolirio, without having a "preliminary report," also speculates and provides wrong information about technical data on the B748 and its operations, while Captain Steeve, who is neither current nor qualified in the B747 did not make any remarks.

That's why I say that you have some obvious issues attacking people.

This is another piece of information that clearly shows that Juan Browne Blancolirio has no knowledge about the airplane, and makes some wrong statements.

You need to take a break from this unwarranted combative attitude.  

 

 

11 minutes ago, LRBS said:

Something is missing here. I didn't mention anywhere that you said "final report". Can you point me to that sentence where you claim that I put words in people's mouths?

 

You need to take a break from this unwarranted combative attitude.  

 

 

You said Final Report here:

23 hours ago, LRBS said:

Can't you wait for the final report and avoid getting involved in...

 

I was never rude or combative, in fact I already addressed this with you:

On 8/17/2025 at 2:55 PM, Matthew Kane said:

Absolutely no anger, I already said I will wait until the prelimary report

 

23 hours ago, Matthew Kane said:

I was never being rude, Enough Said means exactly that 

Edit: Also I never said Final Report, I said Preliminary Report

I stand by what I have already said to you and that is I will wait for the preliminary report rather then engaging in this with you any further Enough Said

52 minutes ago, Matthew Kane said:

You said Final Report here:

I was never rude or combative, in fact I already addressed this with you:

I stand by what I have already said to you and that is I will wait for the preliminary report rather then engaging in this with you any further Enough Said

You said, "LRBS, I never once said Final report that was on you." Absolutely, I mentioned the final report, but where did I put words in people's mouths? That's where the mystery is. 

That's why I say that you are combative, rude, and attack people for no reason. You really need to take it a few notches down; it's a very unprofessional attitude for no reason.

It's very sad to see this. Good luck with your interaction skills.  

Edited August 18, 2025Aug 18 by LRBS

8 minutes ago, LRBS said:

Good luck with your interaction skills.  

And you call me combative - WOW 🤣🤣🤣

Good Day To You Sir

This is starting to feel like an episode of Real Housewives. I think that you both need to "shake hands" and move on.

20 hours ago, dave2013 said:

the 747 limitations state a maximum crosswind landing on a dry runway at 30kts - here they were over 40kts.

That number is the "maximum demonstrated crosswind", not the maximum crosswind.  There is a big difference.  As I've mentioned before after being on several accident investigation boards, a person can't criticize command decisions unless they were in the cockpit and know/knew what the crew knew or thought they knew.