November 3, 200421 yr Or am I dreaming? Given the option of both, which one would be better for FS9?My local hardware provider has given his quotation as such.GeForce Fx 5200 AGP Card [128MB] - Rs 4,200/-ATI Radeon 9600 AGP card - Rs 3,400/-Please enlighten me.Thanks,JineshIndia.
November 4, 200421 yr Hi Jinesh, if you didn't invert the prices, that's great news! Here in Europe it would be the other way around. The 5200 ca.25% cheaper than a 9600. Technically, the 9600 is a bit better, and will not fold with FS's weather and you should be able to use 4xAA @ 1024x. I doubt you could use 4xAA @1024x on the 5200. Only if you're into Linux or 3D glasses and alike, a Nvidia may be more advantageous. You can check this page for Ati specs: http://www.rojakpot.com/default.aspx?locat...&var1=88&var2=0You'll find a link to Nvidia's specs there too. Hope this enlightens, good luck and kind regards Jaap How much is 4200 Rupies in Euros or $?
November 4, 200421 yr Sure! on the double as the sky is blue...!!! I haven't inverted the prices.Thanks for the link.1 US$ = Rupess 47 (approx)Computers and paraphernalia subject to 4.6% sales taxThanks and kind regards,Jinesh.
November 5, 200421 yr Hi Jinesh, the Ati really looks like a good deal then. Here are some European prices for your reference: The 128MB 9600 sells for ca. 4400 Rupies. Or, I recently paid 4700 Rupies for a passively cooled 256MB 9600. A Nvidia 128MB 5200 goes for approx. the same price you were quoted. A 128MB 9600pro sells for some 5100 Rupies. On the technical side: A 9600pro will outperform the 9600 non-pro by ca. 30%. If you want, take another look at the clock frequencies @ Rojak. The 9600pro is ca. 330MHz and the 9600 ca. 220MHz. That's why the 'pro' will outperform the 'non-pro' by a certain margin. It's the only technical difference. Maybe most importantly and my main purpose of responding, Jinesh, please make sure you're really obtaining a 9600 and not i.e. a 9600'SE'!?! 'SE' is ok for mainboards, but hardly ever for display adapters. The low price raises my suspicion, you might have been quoted a SE? So, watch out! Hope this helps and my 'SE-uspicion' is wrong! Cheers, good luck and kind regards again Jaap
November 5, 200421 yr Whoa Jaap, thanks for the pointer.The price quoted was for the 9600, not the 9600Pro.I better watch out!!:-hah Thanks mucho again,Jinesh.
November 5, 200421 yr You're welcome, Jinesh. I hope my words were transparent enough; the 9600 really looks like a very fair deal pricewise. And please just make sure it isn't a 9600-SE, which is a 'cut-in-half' 9600. Cheers, good luck and kind regards Jaap
November 7, 200421 yr personally i would not entertain either of those cards if you intend to run FS, i would even go so far as saying you'd be better off with a second hand ti 4600 which would be faster tand a lot cheaper than either of those cards.
Create an account or sign in to comment