Servos or steppermotors?

[oal331]

I had this question many weeks ago, but now reading another post, i will ask it:Which method is the best for make instruments : servos or steppermotors ? Where else can i use the one or the other?I have some old analog instruments or i could make my own (?), like 737Flaps and Overhead gauges, but i can't understand the difference between these two.thanksEddie ArmaosAthens-Greece

[Guest nauwa]

Servos are limited to less than 360 dergees movement, suitable for instruments like flaps, VSI, IAS etc.Servos know it's position by the self, no need for extra componentsStepper motors can turn endless, useful for altimeter, heading etc.Stepper motors don't know position, need external sensor to know where 0-point is, then it calculate steps to get to wanted position

[Guest MikePowell]

More information here: http://www.mikesflightdeck.com/Iinstrument_panel_3.htmand here: http://www.mikesflightdeck.com/sim_instruments.htmMikewww.mikesflightdeck.com

[oal331]

Thanks a lot both of you !!!Eddie ArmaosAthens-Greece

[Guest LambisGr]

Which of the both ,Servos or Stepper motors are more precise in the movement.If we want to use them for the thrust levers which is the best solution?And both makes small steps?Lambis Greece

[Guest Ferdie]

The best solution... I think... A DC motor :-)

[Guest bjviper]

DC motor for the torque to drive the mechanism. And a potentiometer on each lever for position feedback.Brendan

[Guest Robid]

Can you give more details on how to use these dc motors.I have a collection of dc Servo motors with encoders on the back and I'm not sure how to use them for this purpose.David