mikeat

Beware Mindstar Basic GNS purchase

Recommended Posts

I recently purchased the GNS 430 530 basic software based on my review of the " Features Chart for Basic, Advanced, and Professional ".  My GPS hardware would require 24 events.  The .ini file for the GNS show there were 31 maximum events possible.  The chart stated ">80% of the common events" would require the Advanced Edition.  My choice based on this was then decided upon.  24 out of 31 events = 77.4%.  A no brainer, right?  Wrong, the only way to make the software work was to have 23 out of the 31 events, or 74.1%.  I called Mindstar and was told that the 80% was "just an estimate".  Now mind you 74.1 is not an estimate of 80%, especially when it was written ">80%. 

I was then told that they would not spend anymore time on my problem.  It cost more than the $50 they made from my purchase and then was told they would refund my $50.  Wow, what a way to run a business.  I didn't want the refund, I wanted Mindstar to fulfill what they advertised, give me 77.4% of what I purchased.  Then I was told that "I'll just give you free of charge, the Advanced Edition, because there was no way they were going to redo the software.  I didn't want to look like I was trying to get something for nothing, but if that was the only way to get my 77.4% then so be it.  That was discussed on  September 12, 2018.  And guess what?  I haven't heard anything from Mindstar and at this point I really don't expect to ever hear from them again.

My point, beware of what you buy from Mindstar, it's all just an estimate.  Actually it's just bad business to not back what you say you can do.

Share this post


Link to post
Help AVSIM continue to serve you!
Please donate today!

I notice you didn't use your real name here in our forums, which is required.  That makes it impossible for us to even begin to attempt to sort things out, but in the interest of doing what's right... I'll give it a go.

Your post above states we offered to refund your purchase price and elevate the license so that you could use the 430/530 with the hardware you were wanting to use it with.  So, you were given what you desired (the ability to use the 430/530 with the hardware without paying more) and were given your money back to boot.  Not certain that's a valid complaint on your part, to be honest... but to each their own.

Now as to why you haven't heard from us, perhaps it's because no one knows who you are or how to reach you?

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

JJ knows who I am.  I'm not afraid to tell you that my name is Mike Turner.  This is the 1st time on this forum.  I wasn't aware of always needed to put that in my posts.  And to put what you said in proper perspective you offered to refund, which I didn't want, I didn't want to get something for nothing.  All I wanted was to have the 24 out of 31 or 77.4% of the events.  That's not asking for anything that called already paying for it.  JJ was the one that said he would give the Advanced Edition, free of charge.  I didn't ask for that, he offered it.  And again, I don't necessarily want the Advanced Edition to get what you advertise at >80%.  I'm not at 80% , I can't even get to 77.4%.  I am an honest person who only wants what others advertise and that i've paid for.  If your advertisement would have said >74%, I wouldn't have mentioned anything, I would have bought the Advanced.  JJ was just trying to please me and all I kept telling him was I only want 77.4%, but the free Advanced Edition was his suggestion so that he could move on.  If that's what it takes, then so be it. 

I did not desire the Advanced Edition, I desired the Basic doing what it was supposed to do.  His only way was to to give me the free upgrade.  Don't try to make me the bad guy.  Blame that on your website advertisement.

Share this post


Link to post

It's not about 'bad guy'... it's about being reasonable and straightforward.  I have now read your support tickets and am up to speed.

The advanced license is what is required to use the hardware you're trying to use.  There are twenty-seven (27) basic events for a given GPS unit.  The math of 24 divided by 27 comes to 0.8888~ which exceeds the 0.80 level.  The four additional .ini entries you were seeing were most likely the events only used in training environments.  For training environments, a professional license is required, no exceptions  Here are the twenty-seven (27) events for the GNS front panel:

GPS1_COM_VOL_PRESS
GPS1_NAV_VOL_PRESS
GPS1_COM_FREQ_TOGGLE
GPS1_NAV_FREQ_TOGGLE
GPS1_LARGE_CV_INCR
GPS1_LARGE_CV_DECR
GPS1_SMALL_CV_INCR
GPS1_SMALL_CV_DECR
GPS1_SMALL_CV_PRESS
GPS1_CDI
GPS1_NRST
GPS1_OBS
GPS1_MSG
GPS1_FPL
GPS1_VNAV
GPS1_PROC
GPS1_RANGE_INCR
GPS1_RANGE_DECR
GPS1_DIRECT_TO
GPS1_MENU
GPS1_CLR
GPS1_CLR_HOLD
GPS1_ENT
GPS1_LARGE_GPS_INCR
GPS1_LARGE_GPS_DECR
GPS1_SMALL_GPS_INCR
GPS1_SMALL_GPS_DECR
GPS1_SMALL_GPS_PRESS

That covers both the 430 and the 530 versions.  I believe that clears up the math issue.

As for not hearing from us, on Sept 12 @ 09:48 you were sent a reply from our support system to an email address at a domain of sbcg*****.net, which contained the following:

I have upgraded you to the GNS Advanced.  Use invoice number ####### and your email and follow the instructions below.

https://mindstaraviation.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/115000434846-How-to-upgrade-my-existing-software-from-Basic-or-Advanced-

Here's what the the team provided in terms of your issue with managing the MFD  window:

Resize the window on the size= line

The edges part doesn’t make sense
Or undock it
Right click and select undock


KAP140
https://mindstaraviation.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/213494223-KAP140-How-to-display

I am uncertain what MFD he is discussing as I thought this was a 530 we were talking about.  I will also ask if you ever determined how to use the no bezel version of the 530 as it appeared from your support ticket that you didn't understand that you needed to edit the panel.cfg files and were instead trying to edit the gauge itself.

In short, every effort has been made to assist you.  You have not been mislead, we did not sell you something that you could not use and even addressed the problem rather generously by giving you the license upgrade as well as a refund.  I do not believe a reasonable person can claim foul.

Share this post


Link to post

Math issue!  how about this as far as the ini that I have.  It appears one of our ini is not correct.  Mine has 31. Yours does not have the last 4 and that's is what I received. 

GPS1_COM_VOL_PRESS=
GPS1_NAV_VOL_PRESS=
GPS1_COM_FREQ_TOGGLE=0x11002
GPS1_NAV_FREQ_TOGGLE=0x11003
GPS1_LARGE_CV_INCR=0x11004
//GPS1_LARGE_CV_DECR=0x11005
//GPS1_SMALL_CV_INCR=0x11006
//GPS1_SMALL_CV_DECR=0x11007
//GPS1_SMALL_CV_PRESS=0x11008
GPS1_CDI=0x11009
GPS1_OBS=0x1100A
GPS1_MSG=0x1100B
GPS1_FPL=0x1100C
GPS1_VNAV=0x111100D
GPS1_PROC=0x1100E
GPS1_RANGE_INCR=0x1100F
GPS1_RANGE_DECR=0x11010
GPS1_DIRECT_TO=0x11011
GPS1_MENU=0x11012
GPS1_CLR=0x11013
GPS1_CLR_HOLD=
GPS1_ENT=0x11015
GPS1_LARGE_GPS_INCR=0x11016
GPS1_LARGE_GPS_DECR=0x11017
GPS1_SMALL_GPS_INCR=0x11018
GPS1_SMALL_GPS_DECR=0x11019
GPS1_SMALL_GPS_PRESS=0x1101A
GPS1_RAIM_PREDICTION_FAILURE_TOGGLE=
GPS1_RAIM_ACTUAL_FAILURE_TOGGLE=
GPS1_FAIL_GS_TOGGLE=
GPS1_FAIL_GS_SET=

 

I'm not going to continue arguing, but that email was never delivered to my inbox and neither is it in my trash or spam folder.  If it had been, you wouldn't have been hearing from me.  And as for the gns.ini.  As you can see at mine above there are 31 events and as you can see I // out 4 of them.  Yours doesn't have the bottom 4 of which I have no idea what they are used for.

removing the bezel became a no issue

There's no math problem with the .ini that came with my purchase

Share this post


Link to post

These values:

GPS1_RAIM_PREDICTION_FAILURE_TOGGLE=
GPS1_RAIM_ACTUAL_FAILURE_TOGGLE=
GPS1_FAIL_GS_TOGGLE=
GPS1_FAIL_GS_SET=

are blank, and thus don't count... literally.  They are the four I mentioned that are used for training.  Had they been assigned events, the license requirement would have bumped to Professional.  You have made an assumption that all of the possible entries in the .ini file are the total count of possible events that you can utilize.  I can understand the possibility of confusion there and apologize, however, I have explained to you the math, and it is correct.  I have pointed out that you got both an upgraded license at no extra cost as well as a full refund.

You have misrepresented what actually has happened as well as what support you did or did not obtain.  Here is the screenshot of the message sent to you directly out of our support system:

https://photos.app.goo.gl/NWoP5DEuGvtCwUwq9

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.