Sign in to follow this  

First Impressions and a few suggestions

Recommended Posts

After moving most of my sim time from P3D to X-Plane, I decided to try the P2A demo as using the built in X-Plane ATC is a no-go.  Before trying it I was a bit concerned about the need to use voice control (so I thought), the size of the display on a single monitor, the use of TTS voices etc.  However, I have to say after a few flights all of those concerns are a distant memory and now I’m kicking myself for not trying this sooner!

In short, the interface and setup is well thought out and not time intensive to get a flight going, the actual ATC controlling is excellent, with enough user options to make it configurable to my needs, and with a few TTS voices installed it’s not immersion breaking, though I will probably add additional voices in the future (hopefully with some sales as they aren’t cheap!).  I did notice that some voices say my callsign and some spell it out.  The integration with X-ATC-Chatter is great (I’m a volunteer contributor to that project), and I was glad to read in this forum that assigning ATC chatter by region is a planned feature, to me that would be the icing on the cake.  Perhaps a future evolution of that could even get down to the airport/province/state level for chatter.

A few other suggestions:

-I could be wrong, but i think vectors are usually given in multiples of 5 degrees?  I’ve noticed this is not the case in P2A.

- Would it be possible when departing without a SID to have the controller (when appropriate after take off) clear you direct to your first waypoint rather than providing vectors to intercept on the ground?  (maybe this could be a selectable option or something done randomly).  Listening to real world ATC departures at non SID airports (and even some SID airports) I frequently hear “cleared direct to XXXXX on course”.

- When flying a SID/STAR, it would be nice if the controller sometimes randomly granted a direct-to in order to shorten up the procedure (again maybe a selectable option).

Again, this is a really wonderful program and is now my ATC go to for X-Plane (and P3D whenever I get around to flying in that program again).


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
Help AVSIM continue to serve you!
Please donate today!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this