Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

The AVSIM Community

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

NGX, steel brakes or carbon?

Featured Replies

Normal brakes are much cheaper & more the norm for most airlines especially low cost airlines & older planes. The down side is that they get hot very quick & cause some serious heat transfer to the wheels themselves. On large road vehicles like buses & lorries(trucks) they have devices to assist braking like-exhaust gas brakes & electro magnetic brakes so that the driver can reduce speed or control speed on steep hills without over heating the brakes themselves. Aircraft can use reverse thrust if fitted which assists the slowing of the aircraft. I have seen wheels cracked due to metal fatigue caused by heat. If you use PMDg's 747 & land at an airport with short runways you will get brake temp warning & I've seen a few with wheels on fire during taxi in. In fact it's normal procedure to warn ground crews of the risk of fire. For certification most aircraft have to get up to vr speed then apply full brakes come to a stop & then wait for several minutes to see if a fire breaks out. For me normal brakes make landing more challenging into shorter fields & I'm going to be very interested in PMDG's modelling in their new release.

Mike Summers

Brembo ? It is a Saint who protects all motor bikers wink.png

Gents,Carbons are better no doubt, Although not typically used by many airlines as the expense over the steel brakes is quite large.. Ive been told by many who are in the know, that when in doubt use the steel brake option.

18.png

Shane Walker CYYC - CARS 705 Flight Dispatcher 

I7-2600K @ 3.4GHZ - 8GB RAM - GTX10606GB - W10 - P3DV4.1 - ACTIVESKY -  REX4 + SOFT CLOUDS - EZCA2 - ORBX - FLIGHTBEAM - FSDREAMTEAM -FLYTAMPA - SIMADDONS - AEROSOFT CRJ - PMDG  -737/777/747 - TOPCAT + PFPX 


 

Just a FYI to everyone. Most of the recent planes that Boeing has delivered have had carbon brakes on them. Now i cant say that for certain on the 737 but on the 767, 777 it is true. Also I have no idea what happens to them when they get delivered. So it seems to me very possible that companies prob have both on their fleet. So id say choose the one you like best.

Nick Running

  • Author

i'm currently watching a DVD of transavia airlines 737-700/800 and i got a lot of info out of that.i can't wait any longer for the NGX but i have to. like we all have to thanks

Jeffrey.O

 

777-300ER KLM

Just a FYI to everyone. Most of the recent planes that Boeing has delivered have had carbon brakes on them. Now i cant say that for certain on the 737 but on the 767, 777 it is true. Also I have no idea what happens to them when they get delivered. So it seems to me very possible that companies prob have both on their fleet. So id say choose the one you like best.
That may or may not be true.... However at the company I work for, we are still getting new NG deliveries from Boeing and I can assure you ours has always been steel, and still remain to delivered with the steel. We pride ourselves on fleet commonality, its not in our interest to have to stock two seperate types of parts just for certain specific aircrafts of our fleet, we are similer to southwest in that regard. Any cost conscience company would do the same.

18.png

Shane Walker CYYC - CARS 705 Flight Dispatcher 

I7-2600K @ 3.4GHZ - 8GB RAM - GTX10606GB - W10 - P3DV4.1 - ACTIVESKY -  REX4 + SOFT CLOUDS - EZCA2 - ORBX - FLIGHTBEAM - FSDREAMTEAM -FLYTAMPA - SIMADDONS - AEROSOFT CRJ - PMDG  -737/777/747 - TOPCAT + PFPX 


 

That may or may not be true.... However at the company I work for, we are still getting new NG deliveries from Boeing and I can assure you ours has always been steel, and still remain to delivered with the steel. We pride ourselves on fleet commonality, its not in our interest to have to stock two seperate types of parts just for certain specific aircrafts of our fleet, we are similer to southwest in that regard. Any cost conscience company would do the same.
Very true if i was running an airline i would try and keep all the parts the same. However I was only commenting on what I see in the course of my work, and like I said I don't know about the 737's. Every airplane is different though, has different parts, assemblies etc. based on problems occurring during manufacturing. So in some respects when you are looking at maintenance on your fleet you have to see every plane as separate. I could see having different brakes being just one of those things that could be different from plane to plane. But again i would totally understand wanting to keep things as similar as possible to help mechanics and repairs.

Nick Running

  • Author
That may or may not be true.... However at the company I work for, we are still getting new NG deliveries from Boeing and I can assure you ours has always been steel, and still remain to delivered with the steel. We pride ourselves on fleet commonality, its not in our interest to have to stock two seperate types of parts just for certain specific aircrafts of our fleet, we are similer to southwest in that regard. Any cost conscience company would do the same.
You have a piont there, i think a company should either stick with steel or replace the fleet into carbon otherwise it would be a to much expance for an airliner to have both in stock but replacing a fleet with carbon is also a big big cost price, but he that's the airline industry right?

Jeffrey.O

 

777-300ER KLM

KLM uses carbon brakes on their NG's

Regards,

Frank van der Werff

Banner_FS2Crew_Line_Pilot.jpg

  • Author
KLM uses carbon brakes on their NG's
when the NGX comes out i want to fly how KLM operate their NG's so thanks for that.

Jeffrey.O

 

777-300ER KLM

Indeed, guess my point is its one or the other, usually not both..Lets say a aircraft needs a brake change at a non line maintance base, they now how to fly out a brake clamshell case to swap the one, but lets say the closest maintaince base only has a steel brake available, and the aircraft has carbon, you now cant swap out the unservicable brake because the good one is carbon. Logistial disasters ensue when you have same aircraft types that require different types of parts. The carriers that tend to make good profits have risks like this mitigated. I think the trend is to move to carbon brakes, but its usually all or nothing with carrers regarding this stuff.

18.png

Shane Walker CYYC - CARS 705 Flight Dispatcher 

I7-2600K @ 3.4GHZ - 8GB RAM - GTX10606GB - W10 - P3DV4.1 - ACTIVESKY -  REX4 + SOFT CLOUDS - EZCA2 - ORBX - FLIGHTBEAM - FSDREAMTEAM -FLYTAMPA - SIMADDONS - AEROSOFT CRJ - PMDG  -737/777/747 - TOPCAT + PFPX 


 

If I use Carbon Brakes, Julia Gillard may get an idea for her Carbon Tax... Loser.gif

Create an account or sign in to comment

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.