October 6, 201114 yr In the real world do aircraft ever overspeed for a few seconds and then have to fight to reduce speed to prevent damage to the aircraft. There has been windshear in FSX that has brought me from .79 to .89 in 2 seconds. Obviously this could cause major problems with the aircraft when windshear is doing this. ~Spencer HoeferMOBO: Gigabye Aorus z590 elite | CPU: Intel i9-10900k | RAM: GSKILL RIPJAWS 32GB DDR4 3200 |GPU: Nvidia RTX 2080Ti 11GB| OS: Windows 10
October 6, 201114 yr Yes! After take-off from Melbourne, the overspeed alarm and warning sound during climb (0:00 - 0:10, in german) due to a sudden decrease in headwind, requiring the Lufthansa MD-11 captain to manually intervene to reduce airspeed (because the autothrottle does not react quickly enough). Cheers, - jahman.
October 6, 201114 yr If you are using real weather, it will happen, fsx is no good at updating weather, FSUIPC ( pay) can help to smooth things a little, as do some weather programmes, but it wont stop it.
October 6, 201114 yr Yes it does happen, as far as I'm aware it's the length of time it happens for, that determines whether action should be taken and if it may cause damage to the airframe.AF447 may well have overspeeded due to inaccurate airspeed readings. Apparently in an Airbus this can cause an uncommanded climb to reduce the airspeed as part of overspeed protection. Another A330 since AF447 has had this happen as well.
October 9, 201114 yr If you're talking about mach numbers then I assume you encountered this during cruise. It happens but rarely, either by flying into a tropical thunderstorm cell with a massive change in temperature, or maybe entering the edge of a jetstream core. (Less likely)
October 9, 201114 yr Yes it does happen, as far as I'm aware it's the length of time it happens for, that determines whether action should be taken and if it may cause damage to the airframe. AF447 may well have overspeeded due to inaccurate airspeed readings. Apparently in an Airbus this can cause an uncommanded climb to reduce the airspeed as part of overspeed protection. Another A330 since AF447 has had this happen as well.AF447 was an underspeed stall. Overspeed stalls due to exceeding Mmo lead to an unrecoverable nose-down attitude due to Mach Tuck. AF447 was nose-up all the way down. Cheers, - jahman.
October 9, 201114 yr FSUIPC wind smoothing is the solution for this, but an interrim solution that almost certainly would increase the realism factor as well would be to run at a lower cost index. In real life planes rarely fly m0.02 from their VMO. Especially these days where the price of fuel is really, really high. The airlines wants to save money and force their pilots to fly at incredibly low CI (think around 15-20 CI for Boeing 737NG). Johan Pettersen
October 10, 201114 yr AF447 was an underspeed stall. Overspeed stalls due to exceeding Mmo lead to an unrecoverable nose-down attitude due to Mach Tuck. AF447 was nose-up all the way down. Cheers, - jahman. Yes, I realise AF447 was stalled all the way down but before it entered the stall it had climbed up to its maximum altitude of FL380. I thought this was because of Airbus overspeed alpha prot but looking at it again I don't think it was. There has been an incident since and I think that was what I was thinking of!
October 10, 201114 yr Yes, I realise AF447 was stalled all the way down but before it entered the stall it had climbed up to its maximum altitude of FL380. I thought this was because of Airbus overspeed alpha prot but looking at it again I don't think it was. There has been an incident since and I think that was what I was thinking of!You might be thinking of the Air New Zealand A320 ( x lease XL airways) on test flight southern france.http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10673901 System: MSFS2024, ASUS Rog Stryx Z790-A, Intel i9-14900KF, Asus ROG Ryujin III 360 , Asus Hyperion Case,Rog Stryx 4090 OC, Samsung 970 EVO M.2 SSD, 1Tb Samsung 860 EVO SSD,64Gb G Skill Memory, Asus Aura 1200W Gold PSU,Win 11 ,LG C4 48" 4K OLED Screen., Airbus TCA Full Kit, Stream Deck XL. WinWing FCU, EFIS, MCDU
October 10, 201114 yr Commercial Member Alpha floor is low speed protection and inhibited above Mach .53 I think he is talkng about the high speed protection incident that happened fairly recently on another Air France A330. The aircraft actualy did what it was supposed to do but again the crew made the situation worse causing the aircraft to rapidly climb and almost stall. The problem is how do you properly train for stuff like that when the LVL-D sim cannot accurately replicate the true feel of manual flight at altitude and abnormal flight.Regards Rob Prest
Create an account or sign in to comment