Kermit_70

is P3D simpler than FSX?

Recommended Posts

Here we go again...

I have FSX with tons of add-ons (A2A, ORBX, Aerosoft, REX, UT2, etc) and Saitek hardware. I like my super-realistic GA aircrafts, my live weather and traffic. I don't do airliners. I am looking to use PilotEdge or Vatsim, but have not done it yet.

It's all good, but I feel I am spending too much time tweaking and making sure all is up-to-date and still working... Since I only flight short, very realistic GA flights, I usually don't have OOM problems. I am still stuck in DX9, so no shadows, etc. And of course it is 32bits.

Question: should I switch to P3D v4? Is it worth it?
a) can I transfer most of my add-ons to P3D without purchasing them again?
b) is P3D simpler to customise and use (for example, do I still need all the FSUIPC / SPAD mambo-jambo to fine tune Saitek hardware?)

Cheers

Share this post


Link to post
Help AVSIM continue to serve you!
Please donate today!

1.  With the exception of scenery (e.g. ORBX and some REX products), all your add-ons will have to be repurchased.  Your Saitek hardware will work just fine

2.  P3D IS FSX, at least from a software management perspective; based on your question, there is no difference 

Recommendation:  Hold off until MS releases more information about it's next simulator; the road map is due by August.  It really doesn't make much sense to expend the resources to upgrade now; MSFS '2020' looks like a game changer....I'd wait 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
17 hours ago, Kermit_70 said:

Here we go again...

I have FSX with tons of add-ons (A2A, ORBX, Aerosoft, REX, UT2, etc) and Saitek hardware. I like my super-realistic GA aircrafts, my live weather and traffic. I don't do airliners. I am looking to use PilotEdge or Vatsim, but have not done it yet.

It's all good, but I feel I am spending too much time tweaking and making sure all is up-to-date and still working... Since I only flight short, very realistic GA flights, I usually don't have OOM problems. I am still stuck in DX9, so no shadows, etc. And of course it is 32bits.

Question: should I switch to P3D v4? Is it worth it?
a) can I transfer most of my add-ons to P3D without purchasing them again?
b) is P3D simpler to customise and use (for example, do I still need all the FSUIPC / SPAD mambo-jambo to fine tune Saitek hardware?)

Cheers

LM gives buyers one month to try and return/get a refund if you  are not satisfied.  You may try without any risk.

I switched to P3D with version 2.3. years ago from a DX10 enhanced FSX. There is no turning back. Much better. I am more or less the same kind of flyer you are. 

The UI is now different atfer all these years but not as much as to disorientate a FSX user.  Tweaking is less needed but your mileage may vary depending on your hardware. You can still use FSUIPC (I don't). SPAD I do not know.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Posted (edited)
On 6/24/2019 at 2:00 PM, Kermit_70 said:

It's all good, but I feel I am spending too much time tweaking and making sure all is up-to-date and still working.

Perhaps you're over tweaking.  FSX is FSX.  It hasn't changed since 2006, but hardware has.  A lot of the tweaks that were recommended just aren't necessary anymore.

My suggestion is take a read of the AVSIM FSX Config Guide listed in the right menu.  Very little is needed, especially if you are only interested in GA.

I doubt that I have three tweaks including the HighMem fix and WideApsectView.

Edited by airernie

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now