June 11, 201312 yr Hmmm I could see the thermalright beating the D14 for sure. Reason is I'm 98% sure (haven't been in my case in a while) that the D14 only has 6 heatpipes and the TR looks to have 8. I know people are talking various bits about the chips. Me personally I think I've decided on Haswell. Sure I could get a SB and try to OC to 4.8Ghz but it sounds like it's much easier to hit 4.3 with not much trouble/heat on Haswell. I'd rather have the newer platform for future software/games. I know a Haswell with a decent OC will blow my i7-860 out of the water for something like XP10 for sure. As much as I love FSX, XP10+ is definitely on my radar especially now that they're talking about coming up with a way to auto-populate terminals/buildings at airports. AMD Ryzen 9950X3D | Asrock X870E Taichi | Gigabyte Gaming OC 4090 w/EK waterblock | Full Custom Loop Cooling | Corsair Dominator Titanium DDR5-6000 | Samsung & WD NVME/SSDs | Phanteks Enthoo 719 | Seasonic Vertex Gold 1200W | Keychron Q5 Max | Corsiar Scimitar Elite SE Wireless | Honeycomb Alpha and Bravo | Logitech Pro Flight Pedals | VKB Gladiator Pro NXT L&R handed | MiniCockpit MiniFCU | Alienware AW34DWF | Asus PG279Q | Win 11 Pro
June 11, 201312 yr Westman: The IHS is not TIM, as we all know IHS is the cap on top of the cpu die. The first purpose is to protect the cpu die and its other componets and also help transfer heat (eletromigration). The fact is that you didn't even took the time to know what I was talking about. Bottom line solder witch is metal transfer heat better than the TIM in Ivy and Haswell. The real thing here is honestly and truly trying to help a fellow simmer giving and objective advice. Degradation happens when the cpu handle too much heat or high voltage over time, so having a better conductor of heat one of the factors that degradate the cpu faster helps extend the life of the CPU. Finally if you were not to have one (IHS) you will still need a heat conductor to help the cpu dissipate heat. P.S. obviously if money is no issue buying new cpu more frequently is not a problem, but not all people have the money to do that .... ChaoticBeauty, Exactly my point thank so much for understanding +1
June 11, 201312 yr Author BTW , which mobo is better ? Asus maximus VI hero or the Z87X-UD3H ? Amir friedland.
June 11, 201312 yr Hmmm I could see the thermalright beating the D14 for sure. Reason is I'm 98% sure (haven't been in my case in a while) that the D14 only has 6 heatpipes and the TR looks to have 8. I know people are talking various bits about the chips. Me personally I think I've decided on Haswell. Sure I could get a SB and try to OC to 4.8Ghz but it sounds like it's much easier to hit 4.3 with not much trouble/heat on Haswell. I'd rather have the newer platform for future software/games. I know a Haswell with a decent OC will blow my i7-860 out of the water for something like XP10 for sure. As much as I love FSX, XP10+ is definitely on my radar especially now that they're talking about coming up with a way to auto-populate terminals/buildings at airports. Well no, the standard Silver Arrow is very close to the D14, as I said, there's about two degrees in it. Close acoustically as well. See the reviews. The cooler Ryan linked to is the Silver Arrow SB-E Extreme. The Extreme nudges further ahead of the D14, but it does that as a result of high RPM, very noisy fans. I'm pretty sure that if you took the same high RPM, noisy fans, that are fitted to the Extreme, and put them on the D14, you would get the same cooling. After all, the surface area of the cooler hasn't changed, just the fans. That's the whole point of the "Extreme", it's designed for overclockers that don't care about noise.
June 11, 201312 yr Well no, the standard Silver Arrow is very close to the D14, as I said, there's about two degrees in it. Close acoustically as well. See the reviews. The cooler Ryan linked to is the Silver Arrow SB-E Extreme. The Extreme nudges further ahead of the D14, but it does that as a result of high RPM, very noisy fans. I'm pretty sure that if you took the same high RPM, noisy fans, that are fitted to the Extreme, and put them on the D14, you would get the same cooling. After all, the surface area of the cooler hasn't changed, just the fans. That's the whole point of the "Extreme", it's designed for overclockers that don't care about noise. Ah ok, I assumed the extra heatpipes getting heat to the radiator was what was responsible for some of the extra cooling. AMD Ryzen 9950X3D | Asrock X870E Taichi | Gigabyte Gaming OC 4090 w/EK waterblock | Full Custom Loop Cooling | Corsair Dominator Titanium DDR5-6000 | Samsung & WD NVME/SSDs | Phanteks Enthoo 719 | Seasonic Vertex Gold 1200W | Keychron Q5 Max | Corsiar Scimitar Elite SE Wireless | Honeycomb Alpha and Bravo | Logitech Pro Flight Pedals | VKB Gladiator Pro NXT L&R handed | MiniCockpit MiniFCU | Alienware AW34DWF | Asus PG279Q | Win 11 Pro
June 17, 201312 yr Author Well after some changes done this is the final result :Intel Core i7-4770KGTX 570 OC ARROW SILVER SB E EXTREMEGigabyte GA-Z87X-UD4HG.Skill DDR3 8GB (2x4GB) 2666MHz 11-13-13-35 TridentX + FanSeagate Desktop 3.5" 1TB 64MB SATA3Samsung SH-224 x24 SATA Black DVDThermaltake Toughpower GOLD 750WThermaltake LEVEL 10 GTSAny thoughts ?1.ssd and a new gpu is a future updates Amir friedland.
June 18, 201312 yr If I was you wait to see if the next batch of haswell and see if it turn out to be better. IF not Ivy at this point at least has a little more overclocking potential. P.S. Sandy is still better but is sold out, just my two cents. Good luck man!!!!
June 18, 201312 yr Well after some changes done this is the final result : Intel Core i7-4770K GTX 570 OC ARROW SILVER SB E EXTREME Gigabyte GA-Z87X-UD4H G.Skill DDR3 8GB (2x4GB) 2666MHz 11-13-13-35 TridentX + Fan Seagate Desktop 3.5" 1TB 64MB SATA3 Samsung SH-224 x24 SATA Black DVD Thermaltake Toughpower GOLD 750W Thermaltake LEVEL 10 GTS Any thoughts ? 1.ssd and a new gpu is a future updates Amir... just checking to make sure you are aware that the Silver Arrow "Extreme" is noisy at full RPM? Great cooling of course, due to those high RPM fans. Most of the time you would probably find, the "Extreme" was running at slower RPM, and thus quieter of course, due to the PWM function. That "extreme" cooling capability would be in reserve of course.
June 18, 201312 yr Intel Core i7-4770K If you end up buying Haswell, I really suggest de-lidding it; else no cooling solution will alleviate the problem.
June 18, 201312 yr If you end up buying Haswell, I really suggest de-lidding it; else no cooling solution will alleviate the problem. That depends how high he intends to overclock. No de-lidding is required for reasonable overclocks. My 3770K runs at 4.6 GHz, with no de-lidding. And that's with NH-D14 air cooling. Average results after de-lidding are 4.8 GHz... so not a huge difference, barely a few frames per second in FSX. So far, it looks like the 4770K is achieving 4.4 to 4.5 on average, without de-lidding, and the architecture is faster of course.
June 18, 201312 yr Author The noise is fine.. about delidding , 4.5 even 4.4 is good for me and it seemes that you can get it with an average chip... so I hope I wont need it .. Amir friedland.
June 18, 201312 yr Author Final moment budget problem forced me to go on the NHD14 instead of the Silver arrow...Its just costs me 80 $ less because If I will be going on the silver arrow I need to buy it from amazon and the taxes in my country makes it double price...I can pick the nh-d14 in a local store for 90 $.. so this is way I am going with the nhd14.What do you think ? Amir friedland.
June 19, 201312 yr Final moment budget problem forced me to go on the NHD14 instead of the Silver arrow... Its just costs me 80 $ less because If I will be going on the silver arrow I need to buy it from amazon and the taxes in my country makes it double price... I can pick the nh-d14 in a local store for 90 $.. so this is way I am going with the nhd14. What do you think ? NHD 14 is gonna do the job pretty well. Enjoy your new build Samo Ashor
June 19, 201312 yr Final moment budget problem forced me to go on the NHD14 instead of the Silver arrow... Its just costs me 80 $ less because If I will be going on the silver arrow I need to buy it from amazon and the taxes in my country makes it double price... I can pick the nh-d14 in a local store for 90 $.. so this is way I am going with the nhd14. What do you think ? Well, I have extolled the virtues of the D14 many times on the forum. It's a fantastic air cooler, the one all other air coolers [and closed loop water coolers] try to beat. Some have achieved that, by merely a few degrees, and many by simply mounting high RPM noisy fans. So yes, I have no doubt that you will be very pleased with the performance of the D14. If it fits in your enclosure of course... do check.
June 19, 201312 yr I can pick the nh-d14 in a local store for 90 $.. so this is way I am going with the nhd14. What do you think ? You'll bend your motherboard, kid. Think of: A Christmas Story - "You'll shoot your eye out, kid."
Create an account or sign in to comment