Jump to content

Sign in to follow this  
AtlanticAviator

Is it time to upgrade a 2600k for P3D?

Recommended Posts

Hello Everyone,

I'm aware there are various threads discussing whether or not it would be worthwhile upgrading a 2nd Gen i7 2600k to the latest tech, in order to take full advantage of what P3D has to offer.

I'm currently sitting with an i7 2600k @ 4.5, GTX 970 and 8Gb of 1600MHz DDR3. I use P3D V4 but ONLY at 1080p resolution and have no intention of moving to 1440p or 4K. It handles most situations well but the FSLabs Airbus for example has it on it's knees - on fairly medium settings. I look only for a smooth experience and thus not so concerned with 'figures' and 'frames'. I do, however, use all off the typical frame hogs, such as ORBX, AS16/SkyForce 3D, PMDG aircraft and addon scenery etc.

Therefore, that is why I find it difficult to decide if a full CPU/Mobo/RAM upgrade is worth the performance increase or if a GPU upgrade would bring the greatest increase in smoothness to the P3D experience.

Has anyone upgraded from a similar setup (OC'ed i7 2600k) and would recommend the move to an 8th Gen Intel i7 for P3D on 1080p? Or would I be better off waiting to see what the next generation of GTX cards brings to the platform (if anything)?

I appreciate this has been discussed repeatedly on the forum but I genuinely find it very difficult to make a decision as I see such varied opinions.

Cheers

 


Kriss
 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I saw big improvements when I went from a 970 to a 1070, albeit with an overclocked 4790k.  However, I don't use FSlabs Airbus, so couldn't tell you if that is GPU or CPU dependant, however I would guess it's more cpu


P3D v4.5  Toshiba 43" 4K TV

i7-9700k @ 5ghz, 16gb DDR 3200mhz, MSI Z390-PRO A, Zotac GTX1080Ti Mini, Antec Mercury 360, MSI Vampric 010 Case, 480gb SSD Boot Drive, 1TB NVMe P3D Drive, 1Tb Crucial SSD Storage Drive, Saitek Yoke, Pedals, Radio Panel, Switch Panel, 2 x FiPs

UKV6427

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Given your overclock I'd stick with the Sandybridge 2600k a bit longer but invest in a faster graphics card with more memory, I'm sure a 980Ti or 1080 would offer better value for money than the latest i5 K series because P3D is still fairly dependent on single core performance and an overclocked Sandybridge is still fairly competitive in that regard. And you can always move that new graphics card to a new build system in a year, whereas I don't think you'd be moving your existing GTX970 in to a new system.

When your sim is not running as smoothly as you'd like, use utilities like GPU-Z to see if the bottleneck is with the processor or graphics card.

Edited by ckyliu

ckyliu, proud supporter of ViaIntercity.com. Find my spec and settings in "About me" on my profile.

support1.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, AtlanticAviator said:

Hello Everyone,

I'm aware there are various threads discussing whether or not it would be worthwhile upgrading a 2nd Gen i7 2600k to the latest tech, in order to take full advantage of what P3D has to offer.

I'm currently sitting with an i7 2600k @ 4.5, GTX 970 and 8Gb of 1600MHz DDR3. I use P3D V4 but ONLY at 1080p resolution and have no intention of moving to 1440p or 4K. It handles most situations well but the FSLabs Airbus for example has it on it's knees - on fairly medium settings. I look only for a smooth experience and thus not so concerned with 'figures' and 'frames'. I do, however, use all off the typical frame hogs, such as ORBX, AS16/SkyForce 3D, PMDG aircraft and addon scenery etc.

Therefore, that is why I find it difficult to decide if a full CPU/Mobo/RAM upgrade is worth the performance increase or if a GPU upgrade would bring the greatest increase in smoothness to the P3D experience.

Has anyone upgraded from a similar setup (OC'ed i7 2600k) and would recommend the move to an 8th Gen Intel i7 for P3D on 1080p? Or would I be better off waiting to see what the next generation of GTX cards brings to the platform (if anything)?

I appreciate this has been discussed repeatedly on the forum but I genuinely find it very difficult to make a decision as I see such varied opinions.

Cheers

Hi Kriss.  I believe the biggest bang for your buck will be the CPU upgrade at this time considering you are currently on a i7 2600. I have a slightly less capable graphics card (GTX1060) with an i7 8700K (OC'd to 5.0 GHz) and I get very acceptable FSL A3xx performance with middle-to-high P3D settings.

There will definitely be varied opinions here... just letting you know what my experience has been.  HTH!

Update: I have all the Orbx products, FSDreamteam, Flightbeam, FlyTampa, ImagineSim, PacSim, etc. airports, ASP4/ASCA, UTL and many more, so you understand my sim environment.

Edited by dmiannay


Doug Miannay

M1mhPJG.png 1BV5Kt7.jpg

PC Specs: i7-8700K (OC 5.0GHz - HT Off) | ASUS Maximus X Hero Z370 | Corsair Hydro H150i Pro Cooler | ASUS STRIX-RTX2080TI-11G | 32GB G.Skill DDR4 TridentZ RGB 4000Hz  | Samsung 960 Pro 512GB M.2 (OS/Apps) | Samsung 960 Pro 1TB M.2 (Sim/Games) | Corsair H1000i PSU | Fractal Design Define R6 Blackout Case | Win10 Pro x64

Addons: Many Orbx Products | Many FSD/FB/FT/PacS/LatinV/Aerosoft Airports | ASP4/ASCA | UTL at 35% | ChasePlane | PMDG/FSL/A2A Aircraft

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Folks,

While I'm building my 7700K/GTX1070 Ti - - - my 2700K @ 4.7Ghz/GTX970 still does surprisingly well with P3Dv4... Those Sandy's are true work horses...

Regards,
Scott


imageproxy.png.c7210bb70e999d98cfd3e77d7

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Charlatan said:

I saw big improvements when I went from a 970 to a 1070, albeit with an overclocked 4790k.  However, I don't use FSlabs Airbus, so couldn't tell you if that is GPU or CPU dependant, however I would guess it's more cpu

It's mainly suttering with the FSLabs Airbus which leads me to suspect the CPU is the bottleneck with such a complex addon.

8 hours ago, ckyliu said:

Given your overclock I'd stick with the Sandybridge 2600k a bit longer but invest in a faster graphics card with more memory, I'm sure a 980Ti or 1080 would offer better value for money than the latest i5 K series because P3D is still fairly dependent on single core performance and an overclocked Sandybridge is still fairly competitive in that regard. And you can always move that new graphics card to a new build system in a year, whereas I don't think you'd be moving your existing GTX970 in to a new system.

When your sim is not running as smoothly as you'd like, use utilities like GPU-Z to see if the bottleneck is with the processor or graphics card.

I understand your logic, however I'm thinking I could maybe hold off with a GPU upgrade for another few months when hopefully more 1080 and 1080ti cards will be up for sale, at least that's what I hope! :laugh:

8 hours ago, dmiannay said:

Hi Kriss.  I believe the biggest bang for your buck will be the CPU upgrade at this time considering you are currently on a i7 2600. I have a slightly less capable graphics card (GTX1060) with an i7 8700K (OC'd to 5.0 GHz) and I get very acceptable FSL A3xx performance with middle-to-high P3D settings.

There will definitely be varied opinions here... just letting you know what my experience has been.  HTH!

Update: I have all the Orbx products, FSDreamteam, Flightbeam, FlyTampa, ImagineSim, PacSim, etc. airports, ASP4/ASCA, UTL and many more, so you understand my sim environment.

That sounds quite reassuring Doug, and graphics cards can always be easily upgraded or sold at any time really, so that's good to know! I know upgrading my CPU is only a matter of when to pull the trigger, and I think the 8th Gen intel processors are finally convincing me to do so.

7 hours ago, scottb613 said:

Hi Folks,

While I'm building my 7700K/GTX1070 Ti - - - my 2700K @ 4.7Ghz/GTX970 still does surprisingly well with P3Dv4... Those Sandy's are true work horses...

Regards,
Scott

I agree! In most situations the system still performs surprisingly well with even the most complex addons!

Thanks all for your input, much appreciated! Just another quick question, at 1080p would there be much difference in performance between say a 1080 and a 1080ti? as the price difference is substantial of course! :biggrin: Even at 1440p I assume this difference wouldn't be extremely convincing for P3D?

Cheers

 


Kriss
 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm in a similar situation with an i2500K. Waiting to pull the trigger on new hardware real soon but as a reference for bottlenecks I use http://thebottlenecker.com

From what I have seen, the bottleneck with your updated system would be the m/b and cpu running such a high-end gpu. Even my system running a EVGA FTW1070 gets a 30% bottleneck because of my motherboard, an ASRock P68 and the i2500K. BUT...my FSX is still stutter free. I fly the QW 757 with lots of ORBX, UTX NA and AS16 on SSDs, not mechanical HDs.

Regards


Hoping For CAVU --- Chris

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 hours ago, cgbart said:

I'm in a similar situation with an i2500K. Waiting to pull the trigger on new hardware real soon but as a reference for bottlenecks I use http://thebottlenecker.com

From what I have seen, the bottleneck with your updated system would be the m/b and cpu running such a high-end gpu. Even my system running a EVGA FTW1070 gets a 30% bottleneck because of my motherboard, an ASRock P68 and the i2500K. BUT...my FSX is still stutter free. I fly the QW 757 with lots of ORBX, UTX NA and AS16 on SSDs, not mechanical HDs.

Regards

 

I'm looking at the RTX 2070 as a potential GPU upgrade, it seems to be nicely pitched between the GTX 1080 and 1080ti in terms of performance which for 1920x1080 resolution is more than sufficient. 

For the CPU I'm leaning towards the 8086k which can easily be OC'ed to 5GHz without issues. I think this combination of CPU/GPU upgrade coupled with DDR4 RAM would bring P3D to a level not possible with my current system - smoothness is key!

Regards


Kriss
 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, AtlanticAviator said:

 

I'm looking at the RTX 2070 as a potential GPU upgrade, it seems to be nicely pitched between the GTX 1080 and 1080ti in terms of performance which for 1920x1080 resolution is more than sufficient. 

For the CPU I'm leaning towards the 8086k which can easily be OC'ed to 5GHz without issues. I think this combination of CPU/GPU upgrade coupled with DDR4 RAM would bring P3D to a level not possible with my current system - smoothness is key!

Regards

So you want to "take full advantage of what P3D (4.4) has to offer"?  Then you better get a Ti of the 2080 or 1080 variety  ...yeah, I can read, you use 1080P resolution, but you're going to push P3D 4.4 with an overclocked 8086.

I can easily drop a 9 spot on the G thang with the 1080Ti at 1440P with 4.4 half baked and pushed by an I5 8600. <g>

C'mon dudes!


    ROG Maximus X Apex Z370 -- 8086 @ 5.3 / NB 5.0 -- GSkill  @ 4133 c17-17-32~Cr1 1.42v  -- EVGA 1080Ti 6393 -- ROG PG279Q 1440P 150hz -- Corsair H100i V2 --Samsung EVO 850(s) -- Windows7 Pro 64 --Corsair 750X

Ken C

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 12/6/2018 at 1:42 PM, FunknNasty said:

So you want to "take full advantage of what P3D (4.4) has to offer"?  Then you better get a Ti of the 2080 or 1080 variety  ...yeah, I can read, you use 1080P resolution, but you're going to push P3D 4.4 with an overclocked 8086.

I can easily drop a 9 spot on the G thang with the 1080Ti at 1440P with 4.4 half baked and pushed by an I5 8600. <g>

C'mon dudes!

Hahhah I get you!

That was FuknNasty for use of a better expression! 😂

  • Like 1

Kriss
 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes! I went from a 2600k @ 4.8 to a 4790k @ 4.8 and saw a pretty good jump in performance, all around smoother flight. so upgrading to today's tech 8700/9700k would be all together a very nice boost to performance. Go for it!


Flight Simulator - P3D V4.5/V5 | Operating System - WIN 10 | Main Board - GIGABYTE Z390 AORUS PRO | CPU - INTEL 9700k (5.0Ghz) | RAM - VIPER 32Gig DDR4 4000Mhz | Video Card - GIGABYTE RTX2080 OC Monitor - DELL 38" ULTRAWIDE | Case - CORSAIR 750D FULL TOWER | CPU Cooling - CORSAIR H115i CUSTOM LOOP W/ DUAL 280MM RADIATORS | Power Supply - EVGA 1000+ 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Tom Allensworth,
    Founder of AVSIM Online


  • Flight Simulation's Premier Resource!

    AVSIM is a free service to the flight simulation community. AVSIM is staffed completely by volunteers and all funds donated to AVSIM go directly back to supporting the community. Your donation here helps to pay our bandwidth costs, emergency funding, and other general costs that crop up from time to time. Thank you for your support!

    Click here for more information and to see all donations year to date.
  • Donation Goals

    AVSIM's 2020 Fundraising Goal

    Donate to our annual general fundraising goal. This donation keeps our doors open and providing you service 24 x 7 x 365. Your donation here helps to pay our bandwidth costs, emergency funding, and other general costs that crop up from time to time. We reset this goal every new year for the following year's goal.


    18%
    $4,720.00 of $25,000.00 Donate Now
×
×
  • Create New...