FSX-MS Should I get iFly if already PMDG?

[KingGhidorah 209]

First of all, I know there are going to be people that say "use the search function" or "been done to death", and of course I know that.  The problem is, is that so much smack talk has gone back and forth, that I'm find I'm very little farther ahead than I am before.  My only interest in iFly has to do with the P3D.   One of my primary concerns is flight model.  So if I switch from FSX to P3Dv2 (when it's released) what are the primary differences that I'm going to encounter?  I already know that the consensus is that iFly is 2nd best, but when it comes down to using iFly, am I going to go berserk missing the NGX, should I make the decision to fully embrace P3D/P3Dv2?  I'm tempted to buy the FSX version of iFly and then buy it again for P3D just to see, even returning it if necessary, but that takes a lot of time to fully explore, so I'm hoping somebody can give me the Dummies guide to the differences between the two, and relate their personal experiences.

[UnitedExpress4180 4]

I don't have the iFly model, but I can tell you that PMDG's is lightyears ahead of theirs in terms of functionality and overall quality. I would stick with their model if I were you. As for switching to P3D, I have heard that with some modification it is possible to run the PMDG model in it. Not that I have tried it (or that I intend to), and I certainly don't advise it as it violates their EULA, but it is doable.

[metalmike 34]

I can't compare the two thoroughly since I don't have the NGX, but I really enjoy the iFly and if you're using P3D, it would definitely be the better option because it's actually supported for P3D. I suppose it's not quite an NGX but I think you will still be very impressed with it. Aside from visuals which you can judge from screenshots, one big difference that I miss out on with the iFly is the service-based/wear-and-tear failures.

[GSalden 4,657]

I have both and the PMDG is slightly better , not lightyears ahead....

You will enjoy the Ifly in P3D.

[Don t moderate me this way 882]

Both versions are very good; with the iFly's main (only?) advantage being that you can buy a cross.licence (from FS9 to FSX) for a mere USD 15. No such luck with the PMDG version as their NGs are totally different developments.

[FloG 148]

If you already have the NGX, the only point I see in getting the iFly is the fact that one can legally use it in P3D, if you consider that move. If you stay with FSX for certain, I'd save that money, as I believe (don't own the NGX) that PMDG did both the systems and the visual model a bit more detailed.

One thing that immediately comes to my mind in this regard is the HUD, which in the iFly is only available in the BBJ models IIRC, and from the screenshots, the HUD does look a lot better in the NGX. On the other hand, if you want a great variety of models, you might want to consider the iFly, as it features all available (civilian) 737NG models.

[gandy 18]

I have both but i only use the ngx in fsx, both are great examples of the 737 but for me the ngx is the winner, i like its night lighting a lot better, it has better vc textures and the displays are clearer. I find the ifly displays fuzzy and the cockpit textures feel flat. One thing i did notice is that the ngx glass displays are blacklit even in the daytime but the iflys are not which means at certain times of the day it will be a little harder to see/read the displays on the ifly until the lights come on as they rely on the ambeint light to light them.

 

The Ifly has matured in to a really nice addon with the 3.2 version and has some features the ngx does not but then the ngx has features the ifly does not.

[Tatave 57]

The PMDG has some more functionality if you're a rivet counter. If you want better model and texture quality stay with the NGX. 

[Glynn 405]

I don't have the iFly model, but I can tell you that PMDG's is lightyears ahead of theirs in terms of functionality and overall quality.

 

 

 

I wish I had the ability to judge complex addons so well without actually owning them.

Would have saved me a fortune over the years

[ohsirus 241]

I wish I had the ability to judge complex addons so well without actually owning them.

Would have saved me a fortune over the years

 

OMG I was thinking the same thing. Like most have said the Ifly 737 has really matured from when it was first launched, most feedback you will find is from ver 1.X. If I were moving to P3D and wanted a fully capable 737 then I would get Ifly without a second thought. I find Flight Models debatable as everyone swears their is most accurate by their in-house pilots.

[gandy 18]

I wish I had the ability to judge complex addons so well without actually owning them.

Would have saved me a fortune over the years

 

Sadly reviewers tend not to do follow ups when updates are released for some strange reason but lucky there is plenty of users willing to help out and that can be worth more than most reviews that are out dated.

[RWFeldman 159]

Exact case P3D vs FSX. Iv had the PMDG since it's release but am considering the iFly for the new P3D V2 but will no dought wait for the P3D V2 release just to see if any compatibility issues with DX11 or other areas exist. Thought the iFly may not be the NGX it is never the less very good. I had it for FS2004. For FSX ONLY the NGX.  IMO otherwise I dont know a darn thing.

[Cai Zicheng 171]

I don't have the iFly model, but I can tell you that PMDG's is lightyears ahead of theirs in terms of functionality and overall quality. I would stick with their model if I were you. As for switching to P3D, I have heard that with some modification it is possible to run the PMDG model in it. Not that I have tried it (or that I intend to), and I certainly don't advise it as it violates their EULA, but it is doable.

You don't have it; So why do you pretend to know it? You're not even credited to talk about iFly.

[BleedAir 28]

I have the ifly for fs9/fsx and P3D.  BUY IT!  version 3.2 released a few weeks ago is amazing.  I retired the NGX, there's something special about the ifly that makes you love flying it.  The graphics, sound and flight model are awesome.

[Rocky_53 1,579]

I started off with the Ifly and then started flying the NGX. IMO the NGX is streets ahead of the Ifly. The VC resolution, the night lighting, the FDE and the external textures. So, as I say, only MO, but my experience has brought me to this conclusion. BTW my opinion is based on the original release +1 update, so unsure what updates have been made since then to perhaps change my view.