October 15, 201114 yr Coming from AMD myself (965BE & 1090T) I will go ahead and say don't touch AMD with a 10 foot pole if it's for FSX. Sandy Bridge wipes the floor with Phenom II, period.I mean twice as fast or something like that, no kidding. FSX relies on single threaded performance and clock speed. SB has a MUCH higher IPC than Phenom II (and Bulldozer's even lower, go figure) and clocks much higher too.Phenom II runs cooler, yes, in absolute terms only though. Phenoms have a max temp of 62ºC while SB is fine up to 80ºC. Sandy Bridge is a lot more cost effective: even overclocked it draws less powerIt's a no brainer. For FSX, I5 2500K
October 15, 201114 yr These overcompensating violent reactions to the mere mention of AMD are very telling. "Methinks thou dost protest too much." - W.S. Dennis Trawick Screen Shot Forum Rules
October 15, 201114 yr These overcompensating violent reactions to the mere mention of AMD are very telling. "Methinks thou dost protest too much." - W.S. Dennis, I didn't mean it to be a violent response, just somewhat assertive. I can find the link of two or three other guys in this forum's HW section who switched from Phenom II to SB and you can check by yourself what I mean, and that I'm not the only one. If you can't see the difference there might be something else going on with your rigs
October 15, 201114 yr Dennis, I didn't mean it to be a violent response, just somewhat assertive. I can find the link of two or three other guys in this forum's HW section who switched from Phenom II to SB and you can check by yourself what I mean, and that I'm not the only one. If you can't see the difference there might be something else going on with your rigs Going from Athlon II x3 to sandy bridge (both OC'ed & running 65c under prime95) tripled my framerates & made things far smoother. Kenneth Weir My Saitek yoke mod i7 2600k @ 4.7 8GB Gskill CAS7 2x GTX580 SLI Surround + GT520 Accessory Win7x64
October 15, 201114 yr Okay, enough of you guys whom I greatly respect have spoken. I am going to re-rig my fsx computer with the SB and take some before and after comparisons. I'm open to the fact that I screwed up my previous FSX rig. Will let you know. Gosh, this is going to be a lot of work. It'll have to wait a few hours. I'm in between PANC and KSFO. Dennis Trawick Screen Shot Forum Rules
October 16, 201114 yr Just a note on hyperthreading, confirming once again that the i5-2500K is the way to go.Both the i5-2500K and the i7-2600K have 4 physical cores. The i7 supports hyperthreading, which means each physical core can run two threads. Thus the i5 can run up to 4 threads, while the i7 can run up to 8 threads. http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2383921,00.asp#fbid=iJ1IlFOSxAF Most software is still not well multithreaded. Except for highly specialized programs (eg. graphics rendering) essentially NO software supports more than 4 threads. So even in a multi-threaded program (which sounds like FS is not), the i5-2500K is plenty. As others have said it does an amazing job of overclocking. My 2500K is running at 4GHz still using the stock cooler!!
October 16, 201114 yr I think the 2500K i has a 4MB cache and the the 2600K 8MB cache, correct ? And fsx utilises that, I believe. Any advantage with having a larger cache ? System: MSFS2024, ASUS Rog Stryx Z790-A, Intel i9-14900KF, Asus ROG Ryujin III 360 , Asus Hyperion Case,Rog Stryx 4090 OC, Samsung 970 EVO M.2 SSD, 1Tb Samsung 860 EVO SSD,64Gb G Skill Memory, Asus Aura 1200W Gold PSU,Win 11 ,LG C4 48" 4K OLED Screen., Airbus TCA Full Kit, Stream Deck XL. WinWing FCU, EFIS, MCDU
October 16, 201114 yr These overcompensating violent reactions to the mere mention of AMD are very telling. "Methinks thou dost protest too much." - W.S.Sorry Dennis. But still. ___________________________________________________________________________________ Zachary Waddell -- Caravan Driver -- Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/zwaddell Avsim ToS Avsim Screenshot Rules
October 16, 201114 yr I think the 2500K i has a 4MB cache and the the 2600K 8MB cache, correct ? And fsx utilises that, I believe. Any advantage with having a larger cache ?I think it has 6. Best. Miquel Egea.
October 16, 201114 yr I think the 2500K i has a 4MB cache and the the 2600K 8MB cache, correct ? And fsx utilises that, I believe. Any advantage with having a larger cache ?It is my understating that the i7's higher cache is for the ht Kenneth Weir My Saitek yoke mod i7 2600k @ 4.7 8GB Gskill CAS7 2x GTX580 SLI Surround + GT520 Accessory Win7x64
October 16, 201114 yr I settled on the i5 2500K after reading the hardware posts (and some of Zach's - thank you!) ,and I think this is also in a previousthread.http://jetlinesystems.com/performance.phpWhich decided I buy the i5.I overclocked to 4.3Ghz on an air cooler with the GA-Z68P-DS3 mobo and Artic Cooler Exteeme V2.http://www.arctic.ac/en/p/cooling/cpu/57/.html?c=2181I think this product might be discontinued now,but there are plenty of equivalents out there. Jude BradleyBeech Baron: Uh, Tower, verify you want me to taxi in front of the 747?ATC: Yeah, it's OK. He's not hungry. X-Plane 12 and MSFS2020 🙂 System specs: Windows 11 Pro 64-bit, Ubuntu Linux 20.04 i7-13700KF Gigabyte Z790 RTX-4060-Ti , 32GB RAM 1X 2TB M2 for X-Plane 12, 1x256GB SSD for OS. 1TB drive MSFS2020
October 16, 201114 yr Don't limit yourself to Intel. I have several computers. One of them has a Sandy Bridge, another has an AMD Phenom II. The AMD performs as well as the Sandy Bridge and outperforms SB when overclocking. (Temps, etc.) Take a look at the AMD. You can save yourself some money. HelloSo an overclocked Phenom II will outperform an overclocked i5 2500K, if only that were true.The new AMD bulldozer 8 core cannot even manage that never mind an ancient architecture such as Phenom II.
October 16, 201114 yr It is my understating that the i7's higher cache is for the htOk, thanks Ken, I read about somewhere, but I am too old to remember. System: MSFS2024, ASUS Rog Stryx Z790-A, Intel i9-14900KF, Asus ROG Ryujin III 360 , Asus Hyperion Case,Rog Stryx 4090 OC, Samsung 970 EVO M.2 SSD, 1Tb Samsung 860 EVO SSD,64Gb G Skill Memory, Asus Aura 1200W Gold PSU,Win 11 ,LG C4 48" 4K OLED Screen., Airbus TCA Full Kit, Stream Deck XL. WinWing FCU, EFIS, MCDU
October 16, 201114 yr Most software is still not well multithreaded. Except for highly specialized programs (eg. graphics rendering) essentially NO software supports more than 4 threads. So even in a multi-threaded program (which sounds like FS is not), the i5-2500K is plenty. Sorry, but Chess programs like Deep Fritz 12 and Rybka 4 support as many threads as are available (8 on my rig). Henri Henri Arsenault
Create an account or sign in to comment