June 19, 20232 yr I7-8700k,Corsair h1101 cooler ,Asus Strix Gaming Intel Z370 S11 motherboard, Corsair 32gb ramDD4,, gtx 1080ti Card, RM850 power supply Peter kelberg
June 19, 20232 yr Rather steep entry into the video claiming that default and other ATC sounds extremely robotic and the first seconds of the "BeyondATC" speech sounds exactly as robotic as the "bad examples" given before... just speeding up the speech does not make it less robotic... Greetings, Chris AMD Ryzen 7 9800X3D, 2x32GB DDR5 6000MT/s RAM, MSI RTX 4090 Ventus 3X, Windows 11 Home, MSFS2024
June 19, 20232 yr Thanks for the heads up! I joined their Discord. Doesn't look like it will replace FSHud anytime soon (also because there isn't any information about the features I am interested in) but it's always interesting to see something new appear. I'll keep an eye on this one.
June 19, 20232 yr It's said to handle VFR which FSHud, as far as I recall, doesn't (yet?). Kind regards, Michael Intel i7-13700K / AsRock Z790 / Crucial 32 GB DDR 5 / ASUS RTX 4080OC 16GB / BeQuiet ATX 1000W / WD m.2 NVMe 2TB (System) / WD m.2 NVMe 4 TB (MSFS) / WD HDD 10 TB / XTOP+Saitek hardware panel / LG 34UM95 3440 x 1440 / HP Reverb 1 (2160x2160 per eye) / Win 11
June 19, 20232 yr 1 minute ago, pmb said: It's said to handle VFR which FSHud, as far as I recall, doesn't (yet?). Kind regards, Michael Not sure I understand the question...? Are you asking if FSHud handles VFR? (Which it doesn't.)
June 19, 20232 yr 17 minutes ago, tup61 said: Not sure I understand the question...? Are you asking if FSHud handles VFR? (Which it doesn't.) No question. I understand FSHud doesn't handle VFR but Beyond ATC is claimed to do it. Kind regards, Michael Intel i7-13700K / AsRock Z790 / Crucial 32 GB DDR 5 / ASUS RTX 4080OC 16GB / BeQuiet ATX 1000W / WD m.2 NVMe 2TB (System) / WD m.2 NVMe 4 TB (MSFS) / WD HDD 10 TB / XTOP+Saitek hardware panel / LG 34UM95 3440 x 1440 / HP Reverb 1 (2160x2160 per eye) / Win 11
June 19, 20232 yr Looks like quite an ambitious project. Good to see another player enter the scene for ATC.
June 19, 20232 yr Sounds *a lot better* than the default ATC voices (and arguably any other ATC program to-date). If it works as advertised, it could be very useful for anyone using the in-built AI traffic engine. The only unrealistic thing for me was the 'Contextual Responses' segment. ATC responses like that are only given in Boston or New York! AMD Ryzen 5800X3D; MSI RTX 3080 Ti ; 32GB Corsair 3200 MHz; ASUS VG35VQ 35" (3440 x 1440) Fulcrum One yoke; Thrustmaster TCA Captain Pack Airbus edition; MFG Crosswind rudder pedals; miniCockpit FCU; CPFlight MCP 737; Logitech FIP x3; TrackIR MSFS; Fenix A320; A2A PA-24; HPG H145; PMDG 737-600; AIG; RealTraffic; PSXTraffic; FSiPanel; REX AccuSeason Adv; FSDT GSX Pro; FS2Crew RAAS Pro; FS-ATC Chatter
June 19, 20232 yr 5 minutes ago, pmb said: No question. I understand FSHud doesn't handle VFR but Beyond ATC is claimed to do it. Kind regards, Michael Ah, haha, sorry, I clearly misread your post. 😉 But yes, if B-ATC can handle VFR that would be a plus! I like FSHud a lot but it certainly isn't perfect yet.
June 19, 20232 yr 2 minutes ago, F737MAX said: The only unrealistic thing for me was the 'Contextual Responses' segment. ATC responses like that are only given in Boston or New York! Agreed. That part felt unrealistic and (extremely) 'gamey'. I do hope it's optional. I do have to say the entire video felt a bit 'gamey'... Edited June 19, 20232 yr by tup61
June 19, 20232 yr 2 minutes ago, F737MAX said: If it works as advertised, it could be very useful for anyone using the in-built AI traffic engine. It's supposed to work with FSLTL and FS Traffic. Edited June 19, 20232 yr by tup61
June 19, 20232 yr doesn't motion if the atc controls the ai traffic just says just detect and talk but is external from the sim like fshud or just use the terrible ia from the sim ?
June 19, 20232 yr 6 minutes ago, tup61 said: Agreed. That part felt unrealistic and (extremely) 'gamey'. I do hope it's optional. I do have to say the entire video felt a bit 'gamey'... It's just advertising. I liked the bits of humour to generate some interest and to differentiate from the competition, YMMV. Good news is, there are alternatives if this one doesn't meet expectations. 6 minutes ago, tup61 said: It's supposed to work with FSLTL and FS Traffic. Sorry, I mis-wrote. I meant in the context of being limited to what MSFS can support, as opposed to a completely external live data feed like RealTraffic/PSXT. AMD Ryzen 5800X3D; MSI RTX 3080 Ti ; 32GB Corsair 3200 MHz; ASUS VG35VQ 35" (3440 x 1440) Fulcrum One yoke; Thrustmaster TCA Captain Pack Airbus edition; MFG Crosswind rudder pedals; miniCockpit FCU; CPFlight MCP 737; Logitech FIP x3; TrackIR MSFS; Fenix A320; A2A PA-24; HPG H145; PMDG 737-600; AIG; RealTraffic; PSXTraffic; FSiPanel; REX AccuSeason Adv; FSDT GSX Pro; FS2Crew RAAS Pro; FS-ATC Chatter
June 19, 20232 yr 23 minutes ago, F737MAX said: It's just advertising. I liked the bits of humour to generate some interest and to differentiate from the competition, YMMV. True. But it's a bit overdone imho, focusing a bit too much on how bad default ATC is. Makes me wonder how serious they are. Mixed feelings. YMMV indeed. 😉 I do notice in the video that they apparently know about transition altitudes (so not 18.000 ft all over the world) so that's a plus already. I also already asked them about QNH. 23 minutes ago, F737MAX said: I meant in the context of being limited to what MSFS can support, as opposed to a completely external live data feed like RealTraffic/PSXT. Ah, okay, got it. Well, it seems to me it's the first, not the latter. And what also seems to be rather disappointing is that it doesn't seem to actually control the traffic (like FSHud (and ONLY FSHud) can currently do. Would be a shame if a new ATC addon still limits itself to what all old ATC addons have been doing (and which most people seems to take for granted, oddly enough). But I asked about this on their Discord so... let's see. I also asked if B-ATC is voice controlled only or not (quite important for me because I don't do voice control). Edited June 19, 20232 yr by tup61
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.