captain420

Dynamic Lighting/Night Lighting in P3D v4

Recommended Posts

This is the one thing X-Plane shines at and I will miss. But since the new P3D v4 now has updated lighting, can someone comment on it. How does it look compared to the previous P3D lighting engine? Is it anywhere close to what X-Plane has to offer, and also which add-on airports currently support P3D's updated dynamic lights? 

I'm assuming that all 3rd party add-on airports must update their airports to include this feature if I'm not mistaken?

Share this post


Link to post
Help AVSIM continue to serve you!
Please donate today!

1 minute ago, captain420 said:

This is the one thing X-Plane shines at and I will miss. But since the new P3D v4 now has updated lighting, can someone comment on it. How does it look compared to the previous P3D lighting engine? Is it anywhere close to what X-Plane has to offer, and also which add-on airports currently support P3D's updated dynamic lights? 

I'm assuming that all 3rd party add-on airports must update their airports to include this feature if I'm not mistaken?

It is very good, massive improvement, but at the risk of being pummeled X Plane is still the king of night lighting.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post

It looks very good, but am hoping that  third parties can eventually make lights look like they do in XP11.    The XP lights are amazing

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post

I don't for you but me my frame rate drop like hell (lost 20-25 FPS) when I'm pointing a building at night

Share this post


Link to post

will the landing lights illuminate the clouds when flying thru weather?

Thank you

John.

Share this post


Link to post

Right now it seems that some aircraft are still using the old night textures, I think that will be fixed very soon. So you can't compare the final result with XP at the present time. One of the beta testers told me that emissive lights will be there if developers using V4 SDK to add them. I guess that would not be difficult to do with SDK available.

JV from ORBX said the current dynamic lighting feature supports 256 light sources in one scene, this feature still needs to be improved in the future. But the night environment in V4 is already miles ahead of V3. ORBX is still developing a project called "Building", that will replace all autogen buildings in the sim. They might have something to say about it in flightsimcon this year. 

Cheers

Share this post


Link to post
2 hours ago, 757FO said:

will the landing lights illuminate the clouds when flying thru weather?

Thank you

John.

Hi John, unfortunately no. But maybe we can expect FSFX Packages to do it. They have the strength to improve the immersion in the sim. 

Share this post


Link to post

Still a little to go

open?id=0B3WlNk525DXITWtSWHNUZ3E4anc

edit: well that didn't work

 

Share this post


Link to post
6 hours ago, kand said:

Its as good as xp11

It's a little bit of overstatement, let's face it. :males:

I love P3D but still... have you seen some XP11 night pics ?

Share this post


Link to post
2 minutes ago, gamer19 said:

It's a little bit of overstatement, let's face it. :males:

I love P3D but still... have you seen some XP11 night pics ?

Entirely agree

I was trying to post a pic to show the difference but cant remember how

Share this post


Link to post
7 minutes ago, glider_uk said:

Entirely agree

I was trying to post a pic to show the difference but cant remember how

What are you talking about glider, just post the damn link. It's all ...automated, no worries.

You're not much tech-savvy aren't you ? :uwe_melk:

S-76C_5.jpg.25013947c73c4cfdfdd21e8ffa57

There. :rolleyes:

edit:

You can actually post one from the (XP11) game and another from real life and ask people which are which. I bet no more than 69% will guess it right. :biggrin:

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
1 minute ago, gamer19 said:

What are you talking about glider, just post the damn link. It's all ...automated, no worries.

You're not much tech-savvy aren't you ? :uwe_melk:

gqor3Z.png

There. :rolleyes:

 

Well considering I own an IT company, no your right :blink:

Share this post


Link to post
5 minutes ago, gamer19 said:

You can actually post one from the (XP11) game and another from real life and ask people which are which. I bet no more than 69% will guess it right

They look great in screenshots but when actually in the sim they have limited draw distance and pop into view

Share this post


Link to post

 

7 minutes ago, Glynn said:

They look great in screenshots but when actually in the sim they have limited draw distance and pop into view

Yep the same issue as in 10 and 11 but XP11 nigh lightning is great, however we have a sub-forum for XP, back to P3D V4 hope with PTA we can adjust some stuff nights still to light..

Love the dynamic light feature lot of possibilities..

Share this post


Link to post

Who flies at night? 99.5% of my flights are in the daytime, the others at dusk. All this raving about XP11's night lighting is just trolling by XP fan boys who yet again are bashing a new sim entering the market. Serious chip on their shoulders and it seems to poisoning almost every topic these days.

Share this post


Link to post

I'm actually more into P3D than XP but whatahell...

aren't the real "fan boys" those who can't take any constructive criticism ?

Night lighting is about the only thing that is better at XP than at P3D, to me.

Now call me whatever you like.

Now we only need one P3D v4 night picture hmm.. where can we get one... lemme see...

19 minutes ago, glider_uk said:

Well considering I own an IT company, no your right :blink:

errr.. ok, I guess.

I change the pic in my post while you still quote the old one. How about my IT skills huh ?

Say, any jobs still available at your company ? =)

Share this post


Link to post
1 minute ago, fta2017 said:

Who flies at night? 99.5% of my flights are in the daytime, the others at dusk. All this raving about XP11's night lighting is just trolling by XP fan boys who yet again are bashing a new sim entering the market. Serious chip on their shoulders and it seems to poisoning almost every topic these days.

What an idiotic statement, 1. who flies at night... A lot 2. We are only comparing, If you would look at the main reason for the thread, which you obviously have not. A question was directly asked about an XP 11 comparison. I own all the current sims and like them all for different reasons. I don't see any reason to be defensive about one or the other. Fact is fact.

  • Upvote 3

Share this post


Link to post
1 minute ago, gamer19 said:

Say, any jobs still available at your company ? =)

There is now...Mine

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
29 minutes ago, gamer19 said:

What are you talking about glider, just post the damn link. It's all ...automated, no worries.

You're not much tech-savvy aren't you ? :uwe_melk:

S-76C_5.jpg.25013947c73c4cfdfdd21e8ffa57

There. :rolleyes:

edit:

You can actually post one from the (XP11) game and another from real life and ask people which are which. I bet no more than 69% will guess it right. :biggrin:

Ah yes agreed, sorry, i was really talking about the landing lights when I made my statement! 

Share this post


Link to post
29 minutes ago, gamer19 said:

What are you talking about glider, just post the damn link. It's all ...automated, no worries.

You're not much tech-savvy aren't you ? :uwe_melk:

S-76C_5.jpg.25013947c73c4cfdfdd21e8ffa57

There. :rolleyes:

edit:

You can actually post one from the (XP11) game and another from real life and ask people which are which. I bet no more than 69% will guess it right. :biggrin:

Ah yes agreed, sorry, i was really talking about the landing lights when I made my statement! 

Share this post


Link to post

But wait.. that's still Xplane !?!  :senyum: :uwe_merm:

Oh you funny fun boy glider... :mo_tt_mulut:

Share this post


Link to post
49 minutes ago, glider_uk said:

What an idiotic statement, 1. who flies at night... A lot 2. We are only comparing, If you would look at the main reason for the thread, which you obviously have not. A question was directly asked about an XP 11 comparison. I own all the current sims and like them all for different reasons. I don't see any reason to be defensive about one or the other. Fact is fact.

Exactly - it is what it is - glad I am done with all that tweaking - new P3D looks like the same old same old to me - to each his own

Share this post


Link to post
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.