Asiana B-777 Reported Down At KSFO

[kaspern83 77]

The media is leaning quickly at Pilot error.

 

Typical of the media.. They most likely looked at the weather.. 10Sm visibility so in that case to them,  it must be pilot error.. 

[Dillon 2,197]

The media is leaning quickly at Pilot error.

 

Going by the pieces of the plane on the runway it looks like the pilot tried to land too early. A tired pilot I guess.

[voske 34]

They looked at the weather, but the main reason that they're leaning to pilot error is the location of the debri field of the tail of the plane (before the threshold) and marks on the rocks between the water and the runway.

[ohsirus 241]

Going by the pieces of the plane on the runway it looks like the pilot tried to land too early. A tired pilot I guess.

Just had an retired FAA Inspector flat out state the pilot caused a tail strike.

[styckx 1,870]

The MSM is so predictable.. Bring in every retired person they can to give something a definitive label based purely on sketchy "facts" and an over abundance of conjecture.

[SVA1181 56]

Yup, and the strike on the actual rock berm at the edge.

You can even see the severly damaged (and lost) main landing gear just near the runway number. Seems a very low landing which lead to a landing gear strike with the runway rocky edge then to a tail strike (loss). Again, may god save them all...

[Peter Z KCLE_EDDN 335]

Liveatc has a tower recording up, I was only able to listen to it once (it appears their server is getting hammered) and from what I could make out there was no emergency declared (the Asiana pilot is hard to hear, probably due to the post landing damage).

 

Of course this is all speculative, but from the point of impact, it sure reminds me of the T7 in Heathrow a couple of years back.

 

Prayers go out to everyone that all hopefully made it out on time.

 

Pete

[shamrockflyer 647]

The media is leaning quickly at Pilot error.

Typical. It is unfair to blame the pilots at this time as you can see they did a pretty good job!

 

I hope sources that claim all 303 SOB that are accounted for are legit.

[DetCord 24]

Caught one snippet where it clearly showed that the triple seven hit the approach apron first, not the runway.

 

I still find it remarkable that the bird is essentially intact after cartwheeling.

[SpiritFlyer 987]

On the surface, the BA 777 crash at Heathrow is disturbingly similar. In that case it was fuel starvation due to high altitude freezing, not pilot error.

[Tom Allensworth 1,532]

I still find it remarkable that the bird is essentially intact after cartwheeling.

 

I am not an aeronautical engineer, but I would conject that because both wings are still attached, that the plane did not roll. In fact the missing left engine and the placement of the right engine would confirm a gear collapse and then a long slide.

[SpiritFlyer 987]

DetCord, on 06 Jul 2013 - 5:06 PM, said:

Caught one snippet where it clearly showed that the triple seven hit the approach apron first, not the runway.

 

I still find it remarkable that the bird is essentially intact after cartwheeling.

No way it cartwheeled at all, or even slapped the runway hard enough to compress the lower fuselage significantly at the mid point.

[Dillon 2,197]

Caught one snippet where it clearly showed that the triple seven hit the approach apron first, not the runway.

 

I still find it remarkable that the bird is essentially intact after cartwheeling.

I don't believe it cartwheeled... Not with the wings still on the bird and a nose looking undamaged. Nothing like Sioux City's DC10. This plane slide on it's belly to a stop.

 

The eye whiteness appears to be using the wrong words to describe what he saw.

[19AB67 16]

http://flightaware.com/news/article/Asiana-777-AAR214-crashes-upon-landing-at-SFO/182

[kaspern83 77]

Here is a better image

https://www.dropbox.com/s/j4jyjyrog07pg3m/777crash.JPG

And Live aerial stream of the scene

http://www.cnn.com/video/data/2.0/video/cvplive/cvpstream2.html